==> Pls visit new site at http://malaysia-today.net/ <==

PAS pls channel your energy to something else and work within the PR's understanding of "saksama"

report abuse

disagree 9

agree 80

Hard-headed fools... keras kepala. Buang masa jer saya undi PAS!!!!!!

Instead of going forward, they're putting pressure on the Ruler, and moving backward instead. Tidak menghormati Raja; tidak menghormati rakyat BERBILANG kaum. Hanya mementingkan keperluan sendiri.

I've had ENOUGH. I will NEVER EVER vote for another narrow-minded PAS in the next election.

report abuse

disagree 24

agree 80

Collect all your PAS people and go to the jungle..
tak paham bahasa.. aku yang melayu pun dah meluat dengan kepala dungu PAS nih..

http://semutmalaysia.********.com

report abuse

disagree 18

agree 72

Sudah lah! One's belief is one's choice. So if you feel strongly some thing or event will make you sin, you just stay away or advise your people to stay away. Don't make such petty matter an issue. If you feel the matter is a big issue, you convince yourself and don't impose or infringe on other fellow human beings. I do not know whether to cry or laugh, Rakyat gave PR a mandate, so work for the Rakyat. If PAS is against the event, just restrict your members (if you can) do not involve anybody else especially the Sultan. The more you talk the more damage you make. There are bigger issues to tackle for the nation, consult Nik Aziz or CM of Perak or any decent person but yourself.

report abuse

disagree 8

agree 72

dont be bloody hypocrite PAS.
channel your energy to something more productive.
Else, suffer the same fate as BN, shipped out.

report abuse

disagree 10

agree 36

PAS, this is a democratic country.
no place for extremism.
Should ponder why other ethnic communities have reservation about the sincerity of you people.

report abuse

disagree 11

agree 40

nuthin' better to do ahh ..... hei dun waste time protesting petty issues

focus on a bigger agenda before we get tired of you

cheers

report abuse

disagree 9

agree 32

Haha.

What PAS did was democratic. They voice out their opinion which they are entitled to.

Isn't that democracy all about?

report abuse

disagree 7

agree 26

I agree that for PAS to voice out their opinion is democratic but to expect others to accept is undemocratic. PAS members wshould opt not to attend the show if they feel that it is against their believe but expecting or forcing others to believe is rather absurd. This will mean to say that if PAS forms the government, every rakyat has to follow what PAS believes in. Another ethnic political party in the making although I thought they are beginning to change. Maybe PAS thought that since they have support from the non Malays noe, they are trying to learn and rule by the sword. I tend to believe that with the kind of mentality the young turks have, the support from the non Malays has started eroding from the day they bring this issue up. Just to bad when the are just beginning to be accepted by the non Malays some young punks in politics spoilt the soup. I am just beginning to think whether our PAS boss statements still stands when he mentioned "He is the only one who can make statements on behalf of PAS" which I saw on Youtube after the elections. If that is so, I would expect him to come up with a statement soon. Goodluck PAS on your political future.

report abuse

disagree 6

agree 28

Dear Pas bro, I know you guys are trying to keep our moral values in check. But you should know your limits. Moral degradation is due to ignorance from lack of spiritual knowledge. Have you forgotten that you are Malay Islam?? Have you lost our beautiful Malay tradition? Be Malay muslims, don't try to be ARAB!!

report abuse

disagree 14

agree 25

Hoi! PAS,
You are staying in Selangor at the pleasureof HRH The Sultan of Selangor.
If you want to bantah here and there, go elsewhere like Afghanisyan or any Arab country.
The Sultan has already made his intention very clear. So can you please shut up?

report abuse

disagree 10

agree 26

Party PAS is wasting the mandate given it to by the rakyat. Selangor citizen are too progressive for you to beat them back with your religious views,in fact PAS you should entirely stop using religion in politics it simply does not work. Selangor is good example for PAS to learn some lessons.

Keep Religion and Race out of Malaysian Politics, you have many other more important issues that require you to use that mandate from the rakyat wisely. Get moving on those now.

report abuse

disagree 4

agree 13

The PAS youth thinking they are the GODS!
What a hell you are in when you try to teach the Sultan about your kind of Islam! Budak2 siasat! Biadab!

report abuse

disagree 9

agree 13

Nonpartisan73,
That is not democrstic, that is misuse of democratic!

report abuse

disagree 6

agree 7

Salahuddin; nama pun sudah tau salah

Lebih baik PAS duduk kampung main lancap saja; korang memang kurang ajar; tak cukup.

PAS is a joke party; bunch of mullah cleric shit heads can't get religious fever out of their little heads

report abuse

disagree 16

agree 16

Adun DAP tak dibenarkan masuk DEWAN kerana tidak memakai pakaian rasmi...KURANG AJAR punya ADUN...menyesal undi DAP

report abuse

disagree 15

agree 17

Salahuddin Ayub, pengkhianat Pakatan. P:entingkan Pas dia sahaja. Jangan nak jadi macam si Haprak.Kenapa tak suruh Astro tutup? Kenapa tak desak wanita-wantita UMNO pakai tudung? Selepas ini kita jangan lagi ikut dia protes harga minyak naik. Biar harga minyak naik!

report abuse

disagree 8

agree 12

Having branches everywhere make them think that Pas is strong and can govern the country all by itself. Pas ni macam beruk yang terjatuh dalam lori yang penuh dengan pisang muda!

report abuse

disagree 5

agree 7

pAs muda balik hidup dlm hutan la !

report abuse

disagree 6

agree 10

Eh budak-budak PAS...dah lah jangan buang masa. Get back to reality. Kalau kau orang tak tahan dan rasa penyannyi tu terlalu seksi dan menampakkan aurat, then jangan tengok... Balik rumah tidur!!!! Stop talking about Islam haram ini haram itu..

Kalau nak protes ha....tunggulah Julai 6 untuk protes kenaikan harga minyak.

report abuse

disagree 6

agree 13

Before we make judgement on PAS Youth's action, should we investigate who or what's the motive behind the whole "PAS anti DYMM Sultan Selangor" issue.

I believe there are more than meets the eyes. Is it possible some "undercovers" within PAS Youth or some "corrupted elements promised with 7 virgins" in attempt to sabotaging PR government.

Who is behind all this? Your guess is as good as mine.

Regards,
-JC Tan

Malaysian with Chinese ethnicity defending PAS.

report abuse

disagree 2

agree 23

let them protest all they want, that's the spirit of freedom of expression. but like the Sultan says, to protest and make such a big hu-hah over such a trivial matter only reflects on the narrow mindedness and the lack of tolerance on the psyche of those youths who adopt a holier-than-thou attitude. looks like one step forward and two steps backward for pas this time round. instead of going to the ground to protest, let's see if they have the energy to also go to the ground to help out the actual drug addicts, prostitutes, mat rempits, etc.. and turn society around for the better???

report abuse

disagree 3

agree 14

looks like PAS actually will never change with their narrow minded ideologies..
Young turks dont even bother with the rulings of His Highness The Sultan Of Selangor..

Maybe its the beggining of the PR's demise huh??

report abuse

disagree 3

agree 7

this is a simple issue. Get JAIS to handle this matter,to allow or not Mas Idayu dan Ratu Rock, Ella to perform. If JAIS can't make decision, next step get advise from DYMM Sultan Selangor.

After that its up to PAS if they want to protest. Its the way of freedom.

report abuse

disagree 1

agree 8

"....next step get advise from DYMM Sultan Selangor"


advise from who??? owner of Hard Rock Cafe and Planet Hollywood?

report abuse

disagree 2

agree 8

this fleet of Pas is going astern!this bunch could be the trojan horse deployed to screw up from within n grave diggers in action to bury Pas!with them around,Pas n subsequently PR would be damaged on the next election!

report abuse

disagree 2

agree 6

PAS Youths seem to have nothing better to do. They must be really stupid. There are alot of important issuses out there and all PAS Youths can think of is to protest the performance of some artists. What is really wrong with them? We definately don't want the future of Malaysia to fall in the hands of those idiots. It is about time PAS be educated.
Are they really stupid that no amout of education can help them?

report abuse

disagree 3

agree 6

Well , i have a strong feeling that UMNO is behind this. It could be UMNO's undercover saboteur guys who joined Pemuda Pas and create problems to tarnish the name of Pemuda PAS and PAS itself. Probably they are trying their best to steer PAS to have misunderstandings with rakyats, royalties, DAP and PKR. Its
advisable for PAS is to screen all their members to find any UMNO undercover saboteur existing in the party. DAP and PKR must help PAS to look into this matter very seriously , otherwise face the consequences of misunderstandings and parties to breakup in the PR govn.

report abuse

disagree 2

agree 15

report abuse

disagree 4

agree 9

DO I DESERVE TO GET -28 WHEN I COMMENTED ON THIS ISSUE ??
I THINK WE BETTER THREAD CAREFULLY WHEN WE DEAL WITH ISSUES INVOLVING PAS .
JUST TOO MANY ISSUES LATELY ON THEM , SEE MALAYSIANS UNPLUGGED UNCENSORED@http://malaysianunplug.********.com/
My message was directed at Tan Sri Khalid as he's the Menteri Besar of Selangor.
Please WAKE UP !!!!!!!!!!!!

Tan Sri Khalid
What are you going to do to control the IDIOTIC , STUPID PAS YOUTH ????
If this is the way Pas is showing its true colors we are NOT going to vote for PAS and Pakatan Rakyat in the next election .
Even the Sultan of Selangor Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah has shown his rage and anger over the protest of rock queen Ella and dangdut singer Mas Idayu performing in the Sultan of Selagor Cup by PAS YOUTH as HYPOCRITICAL and TRIVAL .
When is PAS ever going to learn ??? You better replace the youth heads otherwise we will see you voted OUT in the next general elections and take your brand of religion and politics back to Kelantan .
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -28

report abuse

disagree 14

agree 14

PAS youth is becoming more and more arrogant day by day to the extend of

playing GOD. No one can pass judgement on another person's dressing, these are

the traits of a hipocrite and trying to gain personal interest. Very sickening

indeed and has no respect for other fellow muslim, shit you men! yourway of

professing muslim value is your own shit, why impose on others...this is a big

sin..to impose against the will of others.

The PAS youth are thinking they are GOD, but they are nothing but a bunch of

clowns with shit mentality... please learn from YB MB of Perak how a muslim

should behave in a multi religious country. If you want to behave like Taliban

by all means not n Malaysia, maybe in Afghanistan.

report abuse

disagree 7

agree 8

I have never voted for PAS and was always wary of their ideology. However, this time, RPK had written numerous times that PAS cannot amend the constitution because they do not have a 2/3 majority and we should vote against BN, whether that party is PAS, DAP or PKR.

Now, I suppose we can still maintain that PAS on their own cannot amend the constitution and make this country of ours into an Islamic state. However, they appear to have taken their good showing as an endorsement of their ideology. So, even though we may be secure in that we are not going to become an Islamic state anytime soon, why do we need to put up with their rhetorics? And for challenging our sultan, they should be thrown out of the Selangor state govt coalition. Unfortunately, Tan Sri Khalid is strangely silent on this.

Cheers.

report abuse

disagree 6

agree 7

well PAS youth must take part in 'who is dumbest of them all contest!!!!

report abuse

disagree 5

agree 7

Yo PAS man...

Come on la...you live in a free country...so everyone is free to express their views. You go ahead and protest but at the same time we'll still watch Ella and Mas Idayu sing. It's everyone's rights; and that includes not voting for you during the next General Election. Btw I think Ella and Mas Idayu will probably thank you for the free publicity while you get all the bad publicity. His Royal Highness should just cancel the match and ask Singapore to host it. Btw you'll probably see strip dancers before the game if it's held in Singapore...No wonder no one watches football here anymore..

report abuse

disagree 4

agree 5

ada jugak rupanya orang pakai nama ultraman, tapi otak feudalist. Baik tukar jer nama jadi tun tuah ke or tun teja. that fits "ultraman" better.

report abuse

disagree 2

agree 2

From the quote given by kritz it seems someone must have died and made these two-bit provacateurs god.

1. Islam stand against trangressors - but where in the Quran said anything about songs promoting any particular theme - including those sexual in nature ?

2. Performance should not invite lust - Where did the Quran said one must sing or dress or dance decently ? The Quran was verse you(Kritz) refered to was referring to Nabi's wives as they had a standard to uphold. By all means follow Nabi's wife moderate conduct but why do you have to project such a moral standard on others ?

3. Singing should not mix with drinks and with men and women - where in the Quran said that ?

4. Excessiveness in everything is PROHIBITED - PROHIBITED ? Was it an advice or was it a prohibition ? Don't create unnecessary prohibition where there is none.

report abuse

disagree 3

agree 3

Pemuda Pas dan kesemua kaum kerabat Pas harus tumpukan perhatian dan tenaga mereka ke arah perkara yang jauh lebih penting dan bukannya membuang masa terhadap isu yang remih temih.

Saya bagi satu contoh, Cuba lihat isu Abang Nor dari Trengganu yang mati-mati nak kahwin 4. Sedarkah anda orang-orang yang macam inilah secara tidak langsung yang menjana kepada masalah-masalah sosial yang jauh lebih serius daripada konsert Mas Idayu dan Ella. Tolonggggggg beri kaunseling kepada Abang Nor sebelum nasi yang dah jadi bubur menjadi busuk.....

Izinkan saya menjelaskan isu ini dengan lebih terperinci:-

a) Umur Abang Nor sudah lebih 50 tahun, bermakna beliau yang bekerja sebagai
drebar lori suka tak suka akan retire tidak lama lagi (mungkin dalam masa 10
tahun).

b) Pendapatan Abang Nor >< RM1500.00, pada ketika ini bini 3, anak 18 orang.

c) Kalau ikut perkiraan purata, jika jadi kahwin 4, tambah 6 orang anak lagi,
jadi jumlah keseluruhan anak beliau akan memcecah 24 orang.

d) Pada suasana ekonomi hari ini, macam mana dengan gaji RM1500.00 dia nak
bagi makan,pelajaran, pakaian dan lain-lain kepada kesemua 4 bini, 24
orang anak termasuk perbelanjaan beliau?

e) Sedar tak sedar atas alasan Poligami Abang Nor akan mengujudkan generasi
baru penagih, pengedar, perompak, mat/minah rempit, mat/minah
ragut, "Sufiah" dan bermacam lagi masalah sosial edisi baru.

Sepatutnya Pas lebih cenderung di dalam isu-isu semacam ini. Cuba fikir dengan
gaji RM1500.00 mampukah Abang Nor kita untuk memberikan pendidikan yang secukupnya untuk kesemua anak-anak beliau? Mampukah beliau memberikan segala keperluan asas yang cukup untuk kesemua anggota beliau?

Kalau kita baca Harian Metro 2 hari yang lalu laporan bergambar, Abang Nor dan kesemua ahli keluarga beliau berdoa supaya beliau dapat kahwin 4

Akhir kata, saya berharap agar PAS dapat berpemikiran lebih terbuka dan pandang jauh demi kebaikan bersama. Sekian dan terima kasih kerana membaca emel saya.

report abuse

disagree 3

agree 6

never vote 4 BN.Not vote to PAS. vote go to Dustbin is the best.after winning they change colour.

report abuse

disagree 0

agree 1

To chiongguo!

All scholars have unanimous view on the prohibition of all forms of singing and music that incites debauchery, indecency, or sin. As for musical instruments, given the weakness of the evidence indicating that they are forbidden, the rule to be applied here is the one states that all things are originally deemed permissible as long as there is no Shari`ah text that prohibits them.

Singing is no more than melodious words; if these are good, singing is considered good; but if they are bad, such singing is deemed bad. Talk that contains forbidden content is prohibited. What if that talk is accompanied with rhythm and melody?

Quote from the same link: http://www.islamonline.net/ser...9503544202

report abuse

disagree 1

agree 0

Hellooo Salahudin....arent you a doctor or something....if you are...cant you focus on more relevant issues like healthcare which BN has royally screwed up leaving many Malaysians to die at 40....why do you need to go for cheap publicity stunts like jaga tepi kain artists or singers.....what a disgrace.....nothing better to do....if you are indeed a doctor let me guess where you would have graduated from.....UKM or USM....looks like PAS will never grow up....

report abuse

disagree 2

agree 2

Come next election we the RAKYAT will vote PAS OUT ONCE AND FOR ALL. Damn FANATICS.

report abuse

disagree 1

agree 2

Wahai ahli ahli PAS, sedar tak bahawasa nya negeri Selangor mempunyai Sultan yang berdaulat, maka tolong lah hormati apa jua kehendak dan keputusan baginda. Konset ini di cadangkan atas perkenan Tuanku, dan sebagai ketua negeri Selangor, baginda tentulah arif dan waras dalam membuat keputusan. Pas membetah keputusan Tuanku, bererti oang orang Pas lebih teruk dari DAP yang mana setelah silap mereka memohon ampun sebagi rakyat. Pas adalah seperti rakyat yg langsung tidak menjunjung Sultan dan derhaka. Saya mohon Tuanku jatuh kan saja kepada ketua pemuda Pas Selangor dan Pusat ...... Persona Non Grata....ke negeri Selangor. Daulat Tuanku

report abuse

disagree 1

agree 2

Hey Kritz,

Why is belly dancing not banned in the Arab countries or in the Middle East ??

Don't you think they are very sexual in nature with their bouncing and vibrating somachs and bums !!!!!!!

I bet you if you see them pulsating and grooving you probably wish you'll........ (censored)

So where does Islam forbade these dancing ?

Come on Kritz in religion , everything boils down to your thoughts and actions .

report abuse

disagree 0

agree 2

Jangan biarkan kemarahan kamu terhadap PAS akan memberikan peluang kepada BN untuk memecah belahkan PR. Apakah Ela dan Mas Idayu itu lebih penting dari kekuatan PR. Apakah konsert nyayian Ela dan Mas Idayu itu lebih penting dari kebajikan rakyat ?

Biarlah PAS dengan caranya. Bantahan PAS tersebut tidaklah sampai mengubah kebebasan berpolitik. Janganlah suka mengungkit-ungkit bila anda pernah memberikan undi pada PAS. Percyalah tanpa kesepakatan semua penyokong dari PAS, PKR dan DAP, tidak mungkin BN tergolek seperti sekarang. Janganlah kita hanya fikirkan seolah-olah PAS menang hanya disebabkan sokongan kita sahaja. Tahukah kita bahawa penyokong PAS juga telah memberikan pelaung untuk DAP dan PKR berkuasa sekarang. Janganlah sebab hendak tunjukkan 'sayang' kita pada raja hingga kita terlupa pada perjuangan kita. Jangan disebabkan kebencian yang pernah bertempat dikesumat kita terhadap PAS kini tumbuh mekar kembali. PAS tidak bersalah, dan yang bersalah (jika menentang hiburan itu dianggap dapat pahla)hanyalah pemimpin pemudanya. Janganlah kita terlupa pada konsep berfikiran terbuka dan demokratik. Sesiapa sahaja mesti diberikan hak bersuara.

Kebanyakan pengkritik PAS di atas seakan tidak ikhlas memberikan undi pada calun PR. Kita mesti sedar PR tidak akan menang tanpa pakatan semua parti iaitu PKR, DAP dan PAS. Kadang-kadang pengkritik seolah-olah lebih rela dizalimi oleh UMNO/BN asalkan penghibur dan sultan dapat dipuja. Apakah penghibur dan sultan selama ini memperjuangkan kebajikan rakyat ? Fikir-fikirkanlah!

report abuse

disagree 0

agree 1

Pas have all the right to voice out their opinion on this issue as this is a democratic country. HRH Selangor already in "rage" on this matter and He wanted it to be proceed as schedule. I think we shouldnt question that anymore and should lay it to rest. Rukun Negara stated " Kesetiaan kepada RAJA dan negara". I have nothing against PAS as i do support the during the GE12. I respect Tok Guru Nik Aziz. I also thank PAS that they have supported DAP and PKR during the GE12. Without them and vice versa, i dont think we have 4 states and form the goverment beside Kelantan. I still believe most of us still support PAS but it just that their ideolgy approach and implementation that they do not agree especially the Islamic states issue. PAS should have a moderate approach and understand that each state having a diffrent composition of non muslim and muslim. PLEASE UNDERSTAND the rakyat as a whole irregardless of their race and religion!!!!

report abuse

disagree 1

agree 0

if we all want to uphold freedom of expression, then we must uphold that it is everyone's right to question anything and everyone's right to defend anything, within the laws of course. Just because some people are in rage, it doesn't mean that PAS lose their right to express their views. I do not share PAS youth views on this matter because I believe there are many other priorities. But I respect their views and their courage.

report abuse

disagree 0

agree 0