A+ | A- | Reset
Home arrow The Blogs arrow Letters/Surat arrow The Malaysian Economy is Structurally Dangerous

The Malaysian Economy is Structurally Dangerous PDF Print
Friday, 14 March 2008 17:18

This is not a profound research effort on the economy. It is the contrary. Every ordinary citizen should be able to understand because all the facts and symptoms are clear and plain to see.

The Malaysian economic is inherently and structurally dangerous and this is triggering frantic calls for the NEP to be retained as well as equally urgent calls for it to be abolished. After 50 years of UMNO/BN rule, the economy is shaped like a spinning top which is running out of energy or an enormous water tank with shaky supports – choose your favourite imagery.

In its essence, it is like many South American economies and is giving rise to many of the same dangerous social ills. The Malaysian economy is top heavy and weak at the base. This makes it dangerously unstable and gives rise to social ills that may finally topple it unless something is done to correct this.

Among some of its inherent structural deficiencies are:

Top heavy characteristics.

Heavy reliance on big foreign investment.

Heavy reliance on big corporations such as Petronas.

Heavy reliance on a few big movers and wheeler dealers to shore up the economy.

Fawning on rich foreigners and foreign capital. (IDR, etc.)

Weak base characteristics.

Weak local home grown industry.

Weak home grown creativity and enterprise.

Weak small and medium scale industries.

Racial tensions scatter, disunites and dissipates the people

Racial hiring and promotion policies both in govt. and small companies.

Racially targeted govt. economic policies make the situation worse.

There are too many obstacles to concentrating local capital for investment.

 

This situation where the few have gained dominant control of the economy at the expense of the many creates an almost unbreakable vicious cycle where the top heavy segment grows bigger and bigger while the base shrinks more and more. The Malaysian people are turning into servants for foreign and big capital. The Malaysian people have their creativity and dynamism perverted but not destroyed.

How do the Malaysian people express their creativity? It is more and more turning towards destructive channels – anti-social behaviour, crime, corruption, loose morals, despair and self-hate. Those who try to be positive, pour their energy into education but see their prospects only by immigrating to foreign countries or to be skilled workers and servants of foreign and big capital or govt. thus getting absorbed by the same vicious cycle.

Some of the symptoms manifest by our dangerously imbalanced economic structure are:

Vulgar and obscene lifestyle and spending by the rich and powerful.

Even the middle class can afford maids and servants.

While there is long term chronic unemployment Immigrant labour is imported by the millions as cheap labour

While our graduates have no work or forced to sell hamburgers for a living

Serious crimes such as rape, kidnappings and murder mirror S. America

While the police seem to have links to gangsters, prostitution and gambling rings

There is self-hate and fawning on and sucking up to foreigners

While our own citizens are treated as 3rd class passengers

There is lack of patriotism and love of country

While loose morals and anti-social behaviour grip our young

All major religions are hijacked by foreign trends and ideas

While local cults spring up by the dozen

The NEP is meant to correct the imbalance in society

But has given rise to a class of swindlers and money-grabbing crooks

This has triggered calls to abolish the NEP, but equally, because of the weakness in the economic base, it has also retained a desperate demand to keep the NEP. The NEP is not the major problem. We quarrel over peanuts and sweets. The biggest problem we have is the great structural weakness in our economy. We have to find ways and means to break the vicious cycle and develop a stronger base for our economy without toppling over the whole structure. We do not need any more social engineers, we need competent economic engineers desperately.

 

By batsman

Comments (13)Add Comment
...
written by raven1958, March 14, 2008 17:37:45
There is no local creativity or enterprise because Malaysia has one of the worst banking industries. It is basically chetty banking. Its credit cards, houses and cars. No Malaysian bank will lend for a buisness for fear of the buisness going kaput or the loan becoming an NPL. No one wants to take risks be it lender or borrower...for fear of bad loans or bankruptcy....so no go....this country will forever be a slave to FDIs, GLCs and a few blue chip companies. That's the Malaysian economy. The only thing we have in common with the Americans is our flag....not its entrepreneurs......so we will always be a char koay teow or goreng pisang economy.....who to blame.....DAIM!!!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 30
...
written by Malaysiaku, March 14, 2008 17:38:59
I wonder who the clowns were that put our beloved country in this quandry? The NEP can stay in my opinion but it will have to be made more fairly and should be to elevate the poor - irregardless of race. It should be for all races and not just Bumiputras as Chinese and Indians as well as other non-Malays bleeds the same way as Bumiputras. We should all be treated as equal and together we shall work together as one - as Malaysians to rebuild the country.

Pak Lah and his Ministers should now do the honourable thing of resigning. Even its own UMNO people is in favour. Let's see if Pak Lah and his Ministers truly love Malaysia by stepping down.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 26
...
written by ez24get, March 14, 2008 17:59:49
With due respect, the above is not true at all. Not even close!

There are many countries who does not have petroleum, natural gases, palm oil, rubber, tin, abundance of the sea and land, exporters of quality air conditioners, TVs, computers chips, rubber/surgical gloves, etc, etc and yet their economy are alright.

Singapore is one fine example. It's just that Malaysia is managed wrongly and its assets squandered and pilfered away by a corrupt and arrogant government. Get rid of this impediment, Malaysia will soar!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 40
...
written by Chuang Tze, March 14, 2008 18:12:01
Any country's economy will have its inherent strengths and weaknesses. Of course after half a century of plunder by the Umnoputras, the Malaysian economy is nowhere near where it would have been if no economic plunder has not taken place. The extent of the effect of this plunder can be simply seen by comparing Malaysia with Singapore, a nation of 25 million against a nation of 4 million.

A nation with so many natural resources including "black gold", OIL, compared with essentailly a nation that is just a rock sticking out of the water. In 1965, the Ringgit was actually stronger than the SIN dollar by 15%. Now, after 43 years, the SIN Dollar is worth 2.4 times the Ringgit.

This is how much the economic plunder has cost the Malaysian people, this plunder that was made possible by invoking the NEP. The other effect the NEP had was to encourage the "Brain Drain" where the best who were not Bumiputera migrated to where they could make a much better standard of living and without having to report to people who were lesser in ability to them (the Umnoputra with "kulification").

We must make sure the BN loses the next election and make sure BARISAN RAKYAT gets a 2/3 majority but only IF the BR makes the following part of its manifesto:-

Prosecute ALL those Umnoputras and annex all their properties and assets within Malaysia, and abroad, for e.g. Daim's ICB Bank, TDM's and family's many assets, Bodohwi's properties in Perth and elsewhere, Mike Tyson of Selangor's Aussie assets, etc. etc.

Return back to Malaysia, what belongs to Malaysia,
and to ALL Malaysians !!

Soldier on BARISAN RAKYAT !!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 29
...
written by Chuan, March 14, 2008 19:11:57
Let me point this out while we are on this topic- rest assure that there are many Malaysian companies that are hindered by the existing economic policies.

Just look at the current companies in Bursa Malaysia, and the "requirements" that you must meet before you can be listed on the Mainboard...it just turns investors and potential high growth companies off...
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 11
...
written by temenggong, March 14, 2008 19:13:10
That would be an understatement. Malaysia is technically bankrupt without the oil. Look at this:

1997 Investment Expenditure - RM 47 billion
1997 Borrowings - RM 50 billion

1997 Net oil Income, (about)- RM 60 billion

IOW, oil income is not only paying for the entire investment expenditure but it also covers operating expenditure. That means without the oil income, we cannot pay govt salaries!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 13
...
written by Flex Tan, March 14, 2008 19:23:16
GOOD THAT BARISAN NATIONAL STILL HOLDS OFFICE (ASKED TO BE RESPONSIBLED) FOR THEIR MISMANAGEMENT WITH SIMPLER MAJORITY IN FEDERAL GOVT.

THE QUESTION NOW IS, HOW ARE THEY GONNA OVER-TURN THE EVENTUAL ... WITH THE RAKYAT WATCH EVERY MOVES THEY MAKE.....

OR THEY STILL BLAME OTHERS FOR THEIR MISGIVINGS...
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 4
...
written by hiro, March 14, 2008 20:14:04
We have the financial resources to reform the economy. The real problem is the rent mindset. The Opposition has work cut out for them to demonstrate that with the rent mindset removed, overall economy, including those who have benefited from NEP at the expense of other Malaysians, can earn a good living - provided they work for it. But better late than never.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by chiongguo, March 14, 2008 22:07:05
This was taken from soc.culture.malaysia. I think the poster has a point and PM is playing a dangerous game playing to the gallery. At a time when he is expected to demonstrate leadership he had chosen to play the race card to bolster up his flagging popularity. These 2 reports basically was an admission by Pak lalalala that NEP is defunct and is being replaced by MAPEN. Could representation be made to this advisory council ? If so then the above analysis by batsman should be presented to them.


---- Post from Soc.culture.malaysia
You all must have read this I'm sure, (Don't stop, keep reading to the end, interesting)
http://www.nst.com.my/Current_News/NST/Wednesday/Frontpage/2008031218...

PM warns Lim over NEP's exclusion in Penang
Bernama

PUTRAJAYA, Wed: 2008/03/12

Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi has warned Penang
Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng not to make statements that could stoke racial tensions.
Lim, after his swearing-in as the new Penang Chief Minister on
Tuesday, told reporters that the DAP-led state government would notpractice the New Economic Policy.

He had also said that the NEP, which was introduced in 1971 after the May 13, 1969, racial riots to eradicate poverty and restructure society, was the source of "cronyism, corruption and inefficiency.'

Abdullah said in between meetings with top civil servants at his
office here that the NEP, introduced by the late Tun Abdul Razak
Hussein, the country's second prime minister, had in fact succeeded in increasing the size of the economic pie and had benefited everyone.

"I would like to ask the DAP which community has been made poorer
because of the NEP" he said. "The (Penang) state government must not try to create an atmosphere which can cause racial tensions."
Abdullah, who is also head of Penang Umno, said the new state
government in Penang should not marginalise the Malays, who are the minority in the state, and other minority groups like the Indians.

"Do not marginalise the Malays. I want to ask Lim Guan Eng what are his plans for the Malays in Penang. What are his plans for the Indians in Penang. What are his plans for other minority groups in Penang"

The prime minister gave an assurance that the federal government would continue to look after the lower-income groups in the state and would also continue with the special assistance programmes for the bumiputeras.

======================================================= ==

Now read this from Borneo Post, Tuesday, March 11th, 2008
---------------------------------------
http://www.theborneopost.com/?p=32438

NEP ended in 1991, no more an issue: PM

KUALA LUMPUR: Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi said the issue of abolishing the New Economic Policy (NEP) raised by the opposition parties should not have come up as the policy ended in 1991.

Since then, the government has set up the National Economic
Consultative Council (MAPEN) to be responsible for planning the
development of the country's economy.

"Through MAPEN, many policies had been agreed upon for implementation by the government and among the policies were two policies taken from the NEP, with one being the overall eradication of poverty irrespective of race, and the second dealt with distribution," he said at a press conference after chairing the Umno Supreme Council and Barisan Nasional Supreme Council meeting here yesterday.

Abdullah was replying to questions on plans by the opposition parties, which won several state governments in the recent election, to abolish the NEP.

He said the government would continue to holistically carry out its poverty eradication programmes considering that hard core poverty still existed.

"We have continued to implement the programmes until today as poverty still exist including hardcore poverty even if the percentage has been reduced significantly from the past.

"And this has been one of our successes because we had persisted. We did not assume that there was nothing to be done just because the NEP was over," he said.

On the policy of distribution (of wealth), he said the government has been distributing fairly in line with the economic progress made.

-Bernama

From the same freakin "Bernama", one from the West, one from the East. All he is trying to do is to "FOOL" the Malay again.

(FEAR-MONGERING)
Should he resign now?
People of Malaysia, YOU be the judge !!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 10
...
written by wannabepatriotic, March 15, 2008 02:00:14
If only Bodowi knows what e-c-o-n-o-m-y means...
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
..., Lowly rated comment [Show]
...
written by Uncorruptible, March 15, 2008 23:38:52
This guy, batsman, is an exposed cyber trooper of azalina, paid rm 2000 a month to create havoc at Malaysia Today. Read with caution, but better don't read at all as he writes racial junk. Should not be allowed to grace the pages of Malaysia Today at all. Kindly note RPK and labisman.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Malaysiaputra, March 16, 2008 10:00:07
In terms of local economy, Malaysia is literally bankrupt. Most of Malaysia's Industries are foreign based , merely setting up factories here. If these foreign companies moves elsewhere, what do we have in the local context ? Hardly much.

From the little I know, local manufacturers are important as they form the economic base of the country . All these while , foreign investment are encouraged but not enough is made to grow local industries.

It is easier for foreign investors to move elsewhere than for local industries to do so.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
 
Some Images Hosted With
Thank You ImageShack!
 BLOGGERS AGAINST ISA

Powered and Optimized for:
Malaysia Today by MT-TEAM