A+ | A- | Reset
Home arrow The Blogs arrow Special Reports arrow MIC chief Samy Vellu under pressure from minority Indian community

MIC chief Samy Vellu under pressure from minority Indian community PDF Print
Posted by admin   
Sunday, 24 February 2008 22:55

Active Image

By G Manimaran, Channel NewsAsia

As Malaysians prepare to choose their next government, the minority Indian community has emerged as the group to watch.

Many Indians had taken part in anti-government protests in the past weeks, unhappy with their state of affairs.

The man under pressure is leader of the Malaysian Indian Congress (MIC), 71-year-old Samy Vellu who is also the Malaysian Works Minister.

His decision to stay on as party president has been seen as a controversial move.

However Mr Samy dismissed any unhappiness even within party ranks and has decided to retain his presidency of the MIC.

He dropped two popular vice presidents from the party's list of candidates as he announced his bid for a parliament seat in Sungai Siput.

And not many think that's a wise move, going by the hostility from the very people he claims to represent.

Disgruntled Indians say they have been marginalised by the policies of ruling Barisan Nasional, which counts MIC as a component party.

And they blame Mr Samy, saying he has not been doing much to improve their condition.

On Indian voter said: "Samy Vellu didn't intervene when the Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf) protest happened. There are a lot of problems, they destroyed the temple. Samy Vellu pretends not to know anything. He is a Minister and he has to put forth his views."

Increasingly, they want Mr Samy to resign from all posts and retire from politics but the Works Minister and his team are confident that the MIC has enough support.

The man standing against Mr Samy in Sungei Siput is Dr Jayakumar, a candidate from Parti Keadilan Rakyat.

He said "I think it's good for Malaysia if...Samy Vellu loses. It's good for Malaysia if the two-thirds majority goes - not only good for political parties but good for the people of Malaysia. It will make the government sit up and be more accountable and less corrupt."

But not everyone agrees.

One voter said: "I think the problem here is being a minority. As a minority, when he goes into the Cabinet, you can't expect him to overrule and say look this is what we require because he is going to play the Cabinet line also. So that's where he has probably compromised but he could do more I think. He may shout a bit more, make other people intentions know to the Cabinet."

Mr Samy said: "I am 71. There are leaders who (are older) and are still in power. I don't see any reason that somebody must say that I must retire. Only a person who doesn't do work must retire, only the person who hasn't no knowledge of the community or no plans for the future of the community must retire."

He has won his seat since 1974 and many Indians think that is long enough.

The younger Indians, in particular, feel that after nine consecutive wins, it is time for someone else to represent the Indian community.

Mr Samy has said that this would be his last bid for parliament.

But those who think that it is one term too long, they might just vote for the opposition candidate as a protest to Mr Samy.

However, analysts say Indian community is still likely to support the MIC and the Barisan National because they want Indians to be represented in the government. - Channel NewsAsia

Comments (15)Add Comment
...
written by tom73my, February 24, 2008 23:11:51
Malaysian Indians should get rid of this dead wood fast, the faster the better. Don't wait and waste another 5 years. You will be marginalise more. Overhaul MIC now by voting Samy Vellu out this time. Let other capable leader take over Samy immediately. Actually Bodowi, Najib, OKT, Koh Tsu Koon etc wanted to kick him out but due to BN spirit, too shy to tell that in public, just to give face to this old man. They are 'screaming' for you guys to get rid of him. So people in Sg Siput, be united and just do it. Vote Opposition, not the Independent guy.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 30
...
written by billykbk, February 24, 2008 23:12:40
However, analysts say Indian community is still likely to support the MIC and the Barisan National because they want Indians to be represented in the government. - Channel NewsAsia
************************************88

What?? What sort of reasoning is this? Indians who stand up still want to be represented in the govt by MIC?.....Silly joke!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 21
...
written by drrafick, February 24, 2008 23:21:15
As the DPM had said, the Indian's in Malaysia need to reinvent themselves. At the moment the biggest stumbling block is Dato Samy Vellu. I believe his decision to contest in Sg Siput and his decision not to nominate 2 MIC VP for any parliamentary position is basically to reinforce his own position. It is quite obvious even withing MIC, they are having a split. Samy decision to contest may just has an impact on BN overall performance. I believe, Malaysian Indian's all over Malaysia will vote against BN all because their anger against Samy. I might be wrong but this is my assessment by talking to so many Indian's.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 17
...
written by varvoom, February 24, 2008 23:25:40
Samy vellu will lose so badly he may even lose his deposit, the writing is already on the wall, the end of MIC is neigh.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 12
...
written by Mr Smith, February 24, 2008 23:27:35
However, analysts say Indian community is still likely to support the MIC and the Barisan National because they want Indians to be represented in the government. - Channel NewsAsia
==========================
This Singapore news channel better name that analyst. Come one don't bullshit just to lease this government. You never interviewed any analyst.
Who are these analysts? Why don't you approach me and I will give you my take. I am a better analyst.
At no time in this country's history has the MIC and its president been so shunned and despised by the Indian community. It's unthinkable how he can successfully defend his seat on the face of such rejection. He is as good as a leper among the Indians!
If he wins in SS, then I may I wish him good luck for the next 100 years.
If Samy wins, only God can help the Indians.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 10
...
written by Sutha, February 24, 2008 23:44:50

I TOLD HIM BUT HE NEVER LISTENED!

Told him to remain bald, but he publicly planted pubic hair.

Told him to be faithful to his wife, but has many concubines around.

Told him to make Maaiikka rich, but he stole 9 million telecoms shares. That is hijacking 90%..... for personal use.

Told him to respect Hindraf, but he said "my balls". Now, the balls are disintegrating in thin air.

Told him to keep Subra, so he found another Subra.

Told him to keep all old timers for unity of party and community, but he removed them for being too long in politics. Sami Velu a/l Sunnee is 95 years old but not old for politics.

This bloke wants to die in office to save on funeral expenses, but does not know that all seats in hell has been reserved for Beruks Nazional.

report abuse
disagree 2
agree 26
...
written by zul4kulim, February 25, 2008 00:23:32
Comment from http://zul4kulim.********.com/...medan.html

We expect every Indian and all Ethinic Malaysians, worth the salt in their blood, to support and vote for Barisan Rakyat on the 8th March 2008.

Kick out the arrogant, corrupt and racists BN out of our system.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 15
...
written by AsamLaksa, February 25, 2008 04:38:53
It is true that Samy Vellu's position in the cabinet is compromised as he is the minority. Cabinets stand or fall as one. Each cabinet members takes full responsibility for the decisions of the cabinet. If there is any dissent, it is not openly discussed and if a cabinet member refuse to compromise, then he/she would need to resign form the cabinet post. That's how cabinets work. They are the executive.

What Samy Vellu has done is that he is more worried about his position than the people he is suppossed to represent. He holds a lot of sway in the government but doesn't want to use it. Imagine a situation where Samy Vellu is really against something the cabinet decides, and he decides to resign from the cabinet. Now, he won't get the post back but what it shows is that he'd resign due to principles and it would be a big blow to the government which would then need to quickly go into damage control. There will be lots of questions asked. But Samy Vellu decided to be a party to everything the cabinet decides thus he is also directly responsible for all cabinet decisions.

So, if he knew something was seriously wrong, he would have to put pressure on the cabinet but as you can clearly see from his actions what is more important to him.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by Bigjoe99, February 25, 2008 08:22:36
This freakin excuse that the Indians are handicapped by being minority is crap. Majority rules does not mean minority rights are ignored. We are talking rights. There is no reason for Indian temples, even illegals one, to be demolished without proper planning. All Samy had to do was demand that there be an Indian temple planning committee that works with state governments that will plan it for the community and no one can touch them if the planners say so.

There is no reason why each year hardly any Indians get into medicine in IPTA. Its suppose to be a meritocracy? All Samy had to do was work with Gerakan and MCA to demand that 30% of university places be pure meritocracy based on STPM. Chinese cannot take all the places and few bumis will beat the Indians.

Its a load of crap..
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 5
...
written by mara koman, February 25, 2008 08:32:20

ANy Indian who might vote for samy,,, are also considered to be traitors of Indian Communtiy. ....

-71 years old
-Has done his hair,, in country like Britain, tht alone will be enough to resign in ground of unethical and non professionism.,, that absolutely dispicble
-Failed the Indians
-created gangsterism and rule by gansgsters
-Lies afte lies and lies
-became a spokes man for BN and work against Indian
-Rob millions in Maika sharess..
-He is wrong in very way,, old rotten brains,

Who ever would vote for him,, will be voting for all tht is above,,,

SO KICK THE SAMY OUT FAR FAR TO THE UNKNOWN,,Lets Indians start the new beginning without samy ever in the picture.

report abuse
disagree 0
agree 6
...
written by asguard, February 25, 2008 09:08:06
Don't talk too much.... just get rid of of Semi- no -more value and also the MIC servant.....
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 5
...
written by magen, February 25, 2008 10:13:29
"However, analysts say Indian community is still likely to support the MIC and the Barisan National because they want Indians to be represented in the government"

There was MIC in the goverment for 50 years but 30,000 or it would 100,000 if there is no police road blocks still we go to street to ask our rights, ****ing head samsu drinking beggers would vote for MIC this election.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by joeawk, February 25, 2008 14:01:34
It is good to be represented but ONLY, ONLY if there is real sharing. It will be for the more intelligent Indians to guide the ignorant indians and to tell them that there is simply no sharing but gross discrimination of the Indians by the BN govt.

The Indians, like all the others must know that UMNO cannot go it alone. QWe should not vote for MCA, PPP, MIC or the other component party of the BN.

Even should UMNO win big and the other loses all, UMNO will have to sit down with the opposition to form a coalition govt and it is at that point that a equation can be formulated.

Continueing support for the MIC is a sham. You are telling the UMNO govt to go on screwing you Indians. A fw stupid indians but not the majority.

This is one last chance to seek a new equation and we must booted out the BN and MIC and MCA, PPP, Gerakan must be booted out.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by bodohland_citizen, February 25, 2008 17:40:12
Only the samsu drinking indians will vote for BN and Samy Ulu...he..he..he
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Fart Fart Wah, February 26, 2008 11:26:18
THIS FELLA HAS SOLD OUT THE INDIANS RIGHT OUT OF THEIR WAISTEES AND SAREES...
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
 
Some Images Hosted With
Thank You ImageShack!
 BLOGGERS AGAINST ISA

Powered and Optimized for:
Malaysia Today by MT-TEAM