A+ | A- | Reset
Home arrow The Blogs arrow Guest Columnists arrow Pakatan retains Manek Urai with 65-vote majority

Pakatan retains Manek Urai with 65-vote majority PDF Print
Posted by admin   
Tuesday, 14 July 2009 21:52

“This is also something for Najib to take cognizance of. If in the really rural Malay heartland, he can’t win a by-election, what hope does he have in the west coast  mixed-areas?”

By Wong Choon Mei, Suara Keadilan

After a shocking roller coaster vote count, Pakatan Rakyat managed to stave off its arch rival Umno-BN to retain the Manek Urai state seat in Kelantan.

After a final recount, PAS candidate Mohd Fauzi Abdullah beat Umno’s Tuan Aziz Tuan Mat by just 65 votes, far short of the minimum 1,700 predicted by election director Abdul Fatah Harun.

Until now, PAS supporters are in shock, wondering what went wrong. Pakatan officials had a tough time maintaining calm as they cried foul, “What happened to our votes?” A huge traffic jam had delayed the counting process by at least an hour.

Nevertheless, PKR strategic affairs director Tian Chua expressed gratitude for the win, saying that whatever happened and no matter how close the shave, the victory showed Prime Minister Najib Razak was still unable to snap the Umno-BN’s losing streak, despite deploying enormous resources.

“Historically, Kelantan PAS seldom wins by-elections. For Mohd Fauzi to win against a new guy, a flashy UTM graduate with all the support of the Umno stars like Muhyiddin, KJ, To’ Pa, is already remarkable. We must be grateful first and then investigate later if something indeed went wrong between the polling and the counting process,” he told Suara Keadilan.

“This is also something for Najib to take cognizance of. If in the really rural Malay heartland, he can’t win a by-election, what hope does he have in the west coast  mixed-areas?”

According to the Election Commission, PAS obtained 5,348 votes against Umno-BN’s 5,283. The by-election was also marked by record turnout of 87.3 percent by 5pm, exceeding its 85 percent target.

Based on exit polls, PAS’ Abdul Fatah had predicted a Pakatan victory at 4pm, forecasting a majority of at least 1,700 to 2,000 votes, more than the 1,352 it won in 2008.

By then, Deputy Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin had already left town in a huff, reprimanding the EC for not taking sterner action against Pakatan supporters, whom he accused of unruly behaviour.

Outstanding turnout

Perhaps both Umno and PAS underestimated their own contest.

To Umno, the goal may have been to wrest the seat by any means – fair or foul and anyhow just to break Najib’s losing streak. To PAS, it may have been to win without substantially losing its previous 1,352-votes majority.

To the residents, there were several burning issues including oil royalty to the tune of RM1.7 billion still owed to the state by the federal government, a multi-million ringgit bridge liking Manek Urai Lama to Manek Urai Baru and a host of other federal government goodies.

But the hottest potato of them all was undeniably the so-called “unity talks” Najib suddenly reignited last month, in a move that nearly split PAS down the line.

Ostensibly to unite the community, PAS members however believe Najib meant to weaken their party and to break it apart from its Pakatan partners PKR and DAP.

“This is probably why we won despite the promise of a new bridge, so many other projects,” said a PAS voter.

“If the Malays wanted one party, there wouldn’t be two big parties Umno and PAS.That after so many decades, the two still exist means the Malays are secure and matured enough to want to pursue different lifestyles, different thinking.

“It doesn’t mean they don’t value Malay unity but they are not stupid. They can tell who is sincere, who is not. It is clear to us Najib is willing to divide the community just for the sake of his political games. This is bad intentions.”

A hectic and emotional campaign

Indeed the past eight days were marked by hard work and emotional campaigning by both the Pakatan and Umno-BN. The former held some 39 ceramahs or political lectures, while the latter held 32.

Finally, the day of reckoning arrived. Amid a huge police presence, voters began moving into the nine polling stations scattered across the small constituency when balloting began at 8am.

The morning began with little fanfare but picked up as both candidates, who are not eligible to vote, visited some of the nine schools used as polling stations for the event. Neither contestant from PAS or Umno could cast their ballot, although both are local because they are still registered as voters in the neighbouring Guchil state seat.

At around 8.30am, Kelantan Menteri Besar Nik Aziz Nik Mat accompanied the Pakatan-PAS candidate Mohd Fauzi Abdullah to SK Peria polling centre, while Umno-BN’s Tuan Aziz Tuan Mat visited SK Manek Urai.

By 9am supporters of both groups had thronged the vicinity of the schools, with frequent shouts of Allahuakbar or God is Great ringing through the air, while traffic jams along the major roads have already begun to pile up.

As the day progressed and the crowd built up, sporadic clashes began to flare up although police action restored control.

EC chairman Aziz Yusof was reported as saying he was unhappy with situation at the SK Peria polling centre and would “come out with a quick decision soon” – cryptic remarks that immediately alarmed Pakatan officials.

“We are still monitoring the situation very carefully because what the EC says is one thing. What we see on the ground is Umno being very provocative. It may be a tactic to scare and keep as many voters away as possible,” Tian had said.

Of oil royalty, fishmongers and new bridge

Manek Urai is just about two hours drive from the Kelantan capital of Kota Baru. It has inadvertently become the centre of a huge power struggle between the Pakatan and Umno-BN after its PAS assemblyman Ismail Yaacob died in May.

The state seat is a Malay heartland where 99 percent of the 12,293 voters are Malay and has at one time or other either tilled the land or fished the seas.

Ignored for decades by the federal government, residents have watched with bemusement the long line of bigwigs from Kuala Lumpur suddenly descending on their peaceful town and trying to convince them that it is now time for ‘change’.

Early on in the campaign, Deputy Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin stepped on toes by belittling Mohd Fauzi, a self-made trader with a thriving fish-wholesaling business.

The DPM described Mohd Fauzi as a mere fishmonger, with the implication that his Umno candidate Tuan Aziz Tuan Mat was superior because he was a UTM graduate and a former manager at government agency Kesedar,

Eager to make up for his faux pas, Muhyiddin recently promised to build a bridge linking Manek Urai Lama with Manek Urai Baru.

But his claim was immediately rubbished by Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim. “Do not talk about the bridge, give back the RM1 billion and let Tok Guru manage it, they talk about RM6, RM7 million because they think people are stupid,” Anwar said.

He was referring the oil royalty claim submitted by Nik Aziz, the PAS spiritual adviser who is popularly known as Tok Guru. Nik Aziz recently invited Najib to an open debate on the matter but the Umno president has refused, citing a variety of reasons that have been criticized as vague.

Even Lee Kuan Yew was not spared

Umno Youth chief Khairy Jamaluddin, who came to campaign, too set up backs by insisting that “unity talks” between his party and PAS would be held despite repeated denials by PAS leaders.

The majority of PAS members are against any form of dialogue that will lead to a merger between the two Malay groups. They distrust Umno and believe that the “unity talks” are meant to weaken PAS and break apart the Pakatan coalition it has formed with partners PKR and DAP.

However, it is in an eleventh hour tactic that Umno is pinning its hopes in persuading voters to return to its fold. Last night, it began putting up posters showing Nik Aziz shaking hands with Singapore’s Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew.

Kuan Yew, who came to Kelantan on an official visit last month, is not a popular figure amongst the Malay community.

The aim of the posters is again to further divide the Malays – seeking to make them wonder why the MB would choose to meet the Singapore leader but reject unity talks with Umno. It of course omits to mention that Nik Aziz has repeatedly offered to host public debates with Najib.

Umno has also been using federal machinery including government and army officers to campaign on its behalf.

In the 2008 general election, the late Ismail beat his Umno rival Zulkepli Omar by a 1,352-vote majority, obtaining 5,746 votes against the latter’s 4,394.

 

Comments (24)Add Comment
...
written by loosecannon, July 14, 2009 22:04:53
This is a wake-up call to PAS and Pakatan. If they continue with their wayward way, the rakyat will abandon them. People are quite fed up with their quarreling and in-fighting. PAS have to decide whether they want to be with Umno or with PR. They can't have it both way.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 101
...
written by alberttan, July 14, 2009 22:20:58
I am sure if Nasha or Mustaffa was the PAS candidate, UMNO would have won by a landslide. Nasha, 'bagi UMNO belakang masuk' MB wannabe, showing up in Manek Urai probably cost PAS 2,000 votes. Hadi cost PAS another 1,000 votes for being drawn into the 'intellectual' discussions with UMNO bait, these 3 clowns are costing PAS the support that Tok Guru have built for so long. 'Ulamaks', not these clowns are nothing more than FU puppets.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 47
...
written by shamadz72, July 14, 2009 22:21:14
Latest result, PR (6) vs BN (1). So confirm BN memang tak boleh menang kat Semenanjung lagi. Harapkan Sabah/Sarawak aje lah

As for loosecannon, remember PAS has never had any good record in by-election in the past before. So a win in a by-election is good enough. Besides, the polling area they lost is the Manik Urai baru and Manik Urai lama due to the RM 7 million bridge bribing by Muhyiddin lah. Also, remember, TG Nik Aziz has put his neck on campaigning over there continuously. So if PAS lose in Manik Urai, it spells trouble to the Erdogan group within PAS.
report abuse
disagree 4
agree 21
...
written by raven1958, July 14, 2009 22:22:09
Did all the Chinese at Manek Urai vote for BN because of the piggy thingy out in Kedah....
report abuse
disagree 8
agree 31
...
written by red1, July 14, 2009 22:27:36
It is a moral defeat for Pakatan Rakyat.
report abuse
disagree 8
agree 43
...
written by SiHangChai, July 14, 2009 22:31:49
What went wrong to PAS even they have won? Simple. PAS is too power greedy Blame it on Hadi & Nasaruddin for wanting to turn PAS into another UMNO. Balme it on PAS for fielding a wrong choice of candidate. Blaming on PAS for its internal issues. And blame PAS for not having $$$ like UMNO buntek to splash $$ in front of voters.
report abuse
disagree 4
agree 51
...
written by cheekhiaw, July 14, 2009 22:33:07
Thieves and half-blinds finely balanced
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 8
...
written by lobster, July 14, 2009 22:39:02
May day May day. Pakatan, this does not look good at all.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 23
...
written by mikewang, July 14, 2009 22:46:45
I think Pakatan needs to do a post mortem and reflect deeply on this.
To many of PR supporters, a 65 vote majority in a safe seat actually means PR lost.

Don't be an ostrich or you'll be buried in the next by election in a not so safe seat.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 28
...
written by medicshan, July 14, 2009 22:48:07
Despite what Tian Chua says, Najib has eroded rakyat's confidence in Pakatan/PAS.
In the hinterland of Islam, Najib should have lost hands down. He didn't. Only the people's faith in Nik Aziz has seen PAS through.

Pakatan, at the rate you are going, Najib might just win the next bye-election. Pakatan must Go and register the coalition. Keep it loose and you will lose.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 26
...
written by Hello Keithy, July 14, 2009 22:50:19
Wake up Malaysians! Watch out ahead. BN's working. If the "mudah lupa" attitude is gonna persist, BN is gonna make a comeback. PR should not put their legs up and relax. You have lots to do. Don't just take this term as a honeymoon. We all have to work harder to continue the March 8 2008 tsunami to future elections. BN under Najib is adopting the "work and not talk too much" approach. We have to realise thay are just making full use of PR's mistakes and working into the minds of Malaysians. Knowing the ppl are easy to please and of course with some handouts to the ppl, they will soon narrow the gap to their majority.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 16
...
written by Semut Jantan, July 14, 2009 22:50:24
Semenanjung 6, Sabah/Sarawak 1.

BN will win big in Sabah/Sarawak; that will be their focus. More important portfolios (already Foreign Ministry bagi shiok) like Education, Finance, Internal, Industrial and Trade ministries will be awarded to East Malaysians to buy their hearts. Malaysians are that easily bought. Vote for BN folks. If East Malaysians could be pacified (sumbat mulut), I am out of Malaysia for good.

Sabah/Sarawak masih tidur lagi, sigh...
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 11
...
written by Hakim Joe, July 14, 2009 22:54:16
PAS forgot about the postal votes, that's why!
If one were to discount these votes, PAS would have won handily.
Wonder why the Opposition candidates never get even 1 vote from these postal votes,eh?

report abuse
disagree 2
agree 12
...
written by IbnAbdHalim, July 14, 2009 22:56:39
Praise be to Allah. A thin majority of 64 votes is still a win and it proves UMNO terburai in Manek Urai.
report abuse
disagree 8
agree 12
...
written by Kampong, July 14, 2009 23:08:23
Does it really matter who wins by what percentage when some are hell bend to have unity talks?. If you are so eager to go to bed with UMNO, don't play dumb when you get a hard one from behind. I mean a kick from the people, not a penatration from UMNO, which they would very much want to do to PAS.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 11
...
written by Daryl, July 14, 2009 23:13:31
Congratulation PAS/PR on the win

I am one of those that wish PAS lose this time to teach them a lesson for the 'haram' unity talk with the evil one. But, I am really glad they vote with reduced majority. My next question is that is there a possibilities for UMNO lose half of the seats they won in PRU-12? I think that is quite a high possibilities even with all these highly publicize PR so call 'in fighting' by the irresponsible MSM news media. My thinking right now is that rakyat totally lost confidence in the leadership of UMNO/BN and is because their reports on all PR news are totally bias and rakyat start to disbelief them.

GO PR and please make yourself a viable alternative option. Start by closing down on public bickering because our MSM are part of BN government.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 14
...
written by malgal, July 14, 2009 23:32:02
take the learning and wise up not dumb down. PAS reels on its head brought on by najib's machinations.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by Rohani Hitam, July 14, 2009 23:35:48
To win by a mere 65 votes in a 12,000 eligible voters state seat is a miseray and to loose the majority from 1,352 in 2008 to 65 is an insult.

The message is clear that PAS has lost much of it popularity thanks to the secret "unity talk" and the embarassing speeches by Hadi Awang and Nasharuddin.

The Malays in Manek Urai are divided along a thin line that any misconduct can sway the vote away in numbers small enough to cause a defeat. This is a message written on the wall for PAS to contemplate. But if it remain arrogant and defiant Pas will loose track on its own menace and stupidity.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 13
...
written by budaktapah, July 14, 2009 23:46:32
may i remind we all again, PAS and UMNO is not the same thing...period. If PR loose the next BE (if any), people like loosecannon etc is responsible. all it takes is just UBN to rock the boat a little bit and then suddenly all hell break loose.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 8
...
written by budaktapah, July 14, 2009 23:50:23
PAS, PKR, DAP is not just about it's leader...PAS, DAP, PKR is the Rakyat..so please remember what we are in for.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 10
...
written by Taiping60, July 15, 2009 00:25:08
Congratulation to Tok Nik Aziz. I believe the credit of winning should go to you, Tok. In spite fighting with limited resources and divided PAS and PAKATAN as well as deep pocket and do anything to win attitude of the BN, your man still win.

All was due to your sincerity. Believe me if PAS' president or his deputy were to contest, Rakyat Malaysia will make sure they loose badly. It is time for both of them to evaluate their positions. Change and succumb to majority wishes or resigned PAS and join UMNO.

As for PKR and DAP, you are no different. The blickering MUST STOP. Focus on doing what are good for the country and nothing else.

We do not want to see another Khir Toyol and the three cross over assemblymen and woman in this country again.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 8
...
written by harryo, July 15, 2009 00:26:52
PR's win is lacklustre, why? May be Hadi and Nasha have played a number on PAS itself? So you can expect worse things to come for PR. PR, first sit down and analyse recent failures and issues in Penang, Kedah, Selangor. Do the PR parties have sincerity among them in resolving issues and problems? Do they have a vision themselves or are they pulling apart? Ask yourself now before GE13. Otherwise it will be sorry for you? Act early.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 5
...
written by temenggong, July 15, 2009 08:08:48
This is a 'loss' for Pas, a real close call, and they better do something about it.

For the moment, Najib and Muhyiddin are making the right moves.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by KHAIRUL HISHAM HASSAN, July 15, 2009 10:28:11
Alhamdulillah. Praise to the Lord.

I (http://khairul-today.********.com) thank God that Islamic Party has won the Manek Urai By-Election.

Whether a person has died because of cancer, or car accident or fighting or the street, or drown at Irama Beach Bachok, he is still considered as a dead man, no matter what is the cause of his death.

By using the same analogy it is not wrong for me to say that no matter whether you won with a majority of 65 votes or 650 votes or even 6.5 votes, a win is still a win. It does not mean if you won with majority of 65,000 votes you will have a seat or chair made from gold in Parliament or those who won with 65 votes majority you will get a chair or seat made from old forest wood!

I am of the opinion, there is no such thing as government money, all are taxpayers' money. The rakyat or the people is the "Shareholders" because they pay tax that later been used for development etc, while the government of the day is just the 'Manager' only. So how come the "Manager" (government) can threaten the "Shareholder" (the voters or people)that unless they vote for the Federal government of the day (BN), they will not get a new bridge. It is fundamentally very wrong for Muhyiddin Yassin to promise that Manek Urai voters will only get the new bridge if BN wins this by-election.

In the same breath, I (http://khairul-today.********.com) would like to REPRIMAND all the Pakatan Rakyat leaders that I can tolerate people who are very stupid but I certainly cannot tolerate with certain PR leaders who are very PROUD of their stupidity with many conflicting provocative statements anong themselves. My high blood pressure 'went upstairs to 88th floor' each time I read silly comments and squabbles among the PAS, DAP and PKR leaders! Wake up PR leaders if you want to be our alternative government!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
 
Some Images Hosted With
Thank You ImageShack!
 BLOGGERS AGAINST ISA

Powered and Optimized for:
Malaysia Today by MT-TEAM