A+ | A- | Reset
Home arrow The Blogs arrow Letters/Surat arrow Faith without Fear: Allow Bibles in Bahasa Melayu!

Faith without Fear: Allow Bibles in Bahasa Melayu! PDF Print
Posted by admin   
Monday, 29 December 2008 16:17

On one hand, you have the ’Towering Malay’, the ‘Cemerlang, Gemilang Terbilang Malay’, the ‘Glokal Malay’ and the thousand other brands of Malay. On the other, you have the type of Malay who’s afraid to read the bible in case he loses faith in Islam. Contradiction? I think so

Reading the Christian Federation of Malaysia’s (CFM) call to rescind the ban on bibles in Bahasa Melayu, we find a good opportunity for the Prime Minister to finally show some resolve. He has after all, stated his wish to see the racial and religious tensions in our country cooled down.  A good way to do this would be to make not only the Bible, but other religious texts like the Gita and Sutras available in Malay as well. Not that it matters much because these texts are also in English which all Malays would know to a degree anyway, but it would be a gesture of goodwill at least.

Sadly, in our country, we need to protect the Malays from the world. We Malays are treated as if our Islamic faith is so fragile that the second we read about any other religion, we would all abandon it and embrace that religion. We should be deeply insulted by this assumption and say so to the government. Moreover, we should also be aware of the offense this would cause to our fellow Malaysians not of the Islamic faith. After all, this ban is implicitly saying that what they consider holy is simply corrupting. While Muslims chose to be Muslims (if they did at all) rather than be any other religion, this does not entail that we derogate any other faith.

Furthermore, what does Quran say about all this? Quran does not seem to shy away from discussion at all. Rather, it talks about the study of all the philosophies available and selecting the best one (39/18). How is one to do this if one does not have access to any other philosophies? Quran itself becomes more distinct and deep when its reader continuously seeks information (41/3). Therefore if our information is curtailed, our very study of Quran is hamstrung. Lastly, we are told to call people to the path with wisdom and to debate them with most beautiful arguments (16/125). How on earth are we to do this if we’re not allowed to know what the Bible says?

Quran does not propagate this faith in fear which our government and the Islamic clergy propagate. Rather, Muslims should be brave enough to intellectually engage with all other religions and philosophies. This engagement isn’t about finding superiority. Indeed, Quran never claims to be the sole source of truth but rather a guardian over truth (5/48).

On the other hand, we have the Malaysian government which seeks to stop Muslims from engaging with anything. We are to become Muslims who live with the fear that our faith in Islam will simply shatter by reading any other text. Is our faith worth anything then, if this is the case?

Lets hope that Badawi who’s a scholar of Islam (when he’s awake) would for once in his career follow through with his resolution and really tries to cool down the racial and religious tensions in our country. As the CFM suggests, having the bible translated into Malay would help this. By reading the bible, Malays would be able to understand the primary source of Christianity which is one of the world’s great religions and civilisations. Inevitable disagreement that will follow is fine, as long as it is in peace.

Farouk A. Peru
www.farouk.name
 

Comments (26)Add Comment
..., Lowly rated comment [Show]
...
written by thegodfather, December 29, 2008 16:40:50
Ihave read the English translation of the holy Quran many times. It's a beautiful book but I have not been persuaded to convert to Islam. Is the faith of Muslims so fragile that they will leave Islam in droves once they read the Bible in Malay??? How stupid can our government be???
report abuse
disagree 7
agree 96
...
written by Jan, December 29, 2008 16:52:49
The govt leaders are such an insecure and inward looking people they refuse to let other people use their language for religious purposes. If they are serious about promoting their language it's time they let go. Not only use Bahasa for translating Bibe works but also of other religions.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 47
...
written by pinsysu, December 29, 2008 17:09:08
1st u think u nid to defend God / religion. next u think God's believers' faith is very fragile & will succumb to any form of temptation. u start building walls hoping to kip things u think it shd be. da world has become so porous dat watever effort u engaged will be futile. time will tell. God loves gentle souls & wants His ppl to spread da message of His love. ppl eventually get tired of being told of a lot of don'ts dat make no sense.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 18
...
written by Pangkis Pangazou, December 29, 2008 17:15:47
The Christians in East Malaysia have been using Bahasa Melayu for quite some time already. We have been having our prayer services in Malay too. There are no ulterior motives for this as some readers of MT have deduced in other forums. A majority of our rural folks speak in Malay and are not well versed in English. I don't think that the usage of Bahasa Melayu will confuse Muslims. It's a question of faith... if you have so little faith in your own religion... then you will feel insecure and think that "others" are trying to convert your people. Have a little faith in your own people and most of all have some faith in your God.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 65
...
written by Farouk, December 29, 2008 17:58:00
Pak Lah's double standards with the graduan melayu thugs:

http://www.peru.name/writing/?p=345
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 8
...
written by Melly, December 29, 2008 18:01:53
Hear, Hear. There is only one outcome with mollycoddling; imaturity. Love them to death, suffocation is the result. Let them have the truth and the truth will set them free.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 6
...
written by non conformist, December 29, 2008 18:08:49
It boils down to this political strategy:
Ignorance is the mother of all bondage.
Keep them ignorant and they will remain loyal Muslim, and supporters of UMNO.

For many hundred of years, the Roman Catholic Church kept the masses ignorant of the Bible... and the effect was the Dark Ages. And with the Reformation, the Bible was translated into all sort of languages, and the darkness was dispelled.

How many Malay Muslim read and understand the Quran? Is the Quran translated into Malay language? I have very intelligent and friendly Muslim neighbors - both husband and wife are lecturers in USM. One day, I asked the husband if he could recommend a reliable commentary (they DON'T call it translation, because Quran is un-translatable, i.e. once translated, it is no more Quran. Only in its original language, it is Quran). What he said left me astounded. "O tuan, I don't read the Quran. It is a very difficult book to understand. We let the iman to tell us what the Quran mean. It would be very difficult for you to understand." In any case, he did asked someone religious teacher and gave me a name, and I obtained a commentary of the Quran in English from the USM co-op bookshop.

I reason to myself, if Quran is Allah's message to man, then surely the all-wise Allah give His message in such a way that EVEN the simple can understand its message. But if intelligent Muslims find the book difficult to understand, then something is quite wrong... May be the Book is deliberately withheld from the people... perhaps in a language that that foreign to them. So Quran must be kept in its pure and pristine language - Arabic... so that its message is kept away from the common people.

The case is ENTIRELY opposite with the Bible of the Christians. Though the original language of the Bible are chiefly Hebrew (Old Testament)and Koine Greek (New Testament), the Bible has been translated into literally thousand of languages, and increasing.

Here are some figures:
Number of languages with some or all of the Bible: 2,355.
Of these, 414 have an adequate Bible,
1,068 have an adequate New Testament, and
873 have at least one book of the Bible.
[2003 statistics from the United Bible Societies]

Let every man have the FULL LIBERTY and FULL ACCESS to whatever information he desires, and let him believe and practice whatever he is fully persuaded.

I believe that is each man's God-given birth-right.

"And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free."






report abuse
disagree 2
agree 31
...
written by ahmadneil, December 29, 2008 18:21:00
I read Koran,Bible,Playboy,Woman,Her World,Time,Newsweek,etc.Reading has nothing to do with immoral.
Our religions are only a guideline.Don't let religion controls you.We control our religion.You can still be Holy if you don't go to church or any place of worship.
report abuse
disagree 17
agree 28
...
written by Michael Sun, December 29, 2008 18:24:20
More than two generations of Malaysians were schooled in Bahasa Malaysia to inculcate and instill patriotism to Malaysia. To the bulk of non-Malays, Bahasa Malaysia is the only language they know to read, speak and write.

Yet today we are still treating the Holy Bible in Malay as a threat to national security under the ISA.

BN should not insult the Malays. The modern day Malays are educated and articulated to read and discern for themselves what is good and bad. I have read text of other religions and yet I have not been converted.

BN and Badawi should show leadership and courage by allowing religious books of other religions to be translated to Bahasa Malaysia.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 24
...
written by Tompios, December 29, 2008 18:34:41
Which one good for Malaysians; Bahasa Melayu bahasa KEBANGSAAN Malaysia or Bahasa Melayu bahasa orang ISLAM Malaysia?

Please, don't put Malaysians in complicated situation! Months ago, Bible in Iban was banned by the authority and the English Christian materials that come to Sabah was caught by Custom Department. This government is totally crazy!! If you bring Bible more then 10 inside your Bible the Custom Department in Kota Kinabalu will hold it and give you M-16 bullets questions! This is too much!!

Jabatan Islam Malaysia, sedikit hormat cuba!!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 20
...
written by Tompios, December 29, 2008 18:35:26
typo error...inside your bag....
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by non conformist, December 29, 2008 18:36:38
Few years a ago, the 'Doulos' ship - the biggest floating bookshop - came to Penang. I took my family along to board the ship to find some bargains. As we were entering the check-point, we saw the warning sign in Malay to the effect, "Muslims not allowed on board the ship". A saw a Malay man with two of his children approaching the guard at the check-point. The Malay guard warned the man, being a Muslim, that he was not allowed to board the ship. The man courteously told the guard, that he was lecturer in USM, and knew what he was doing, and that it was nobody's business telling him what he could and could not go on board the ship and peruse and buy what he wanted!" They were some of the sweetest and sanest words I heard from a fellow Malaysian. May his tribe increase.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 33
...
written by Krazee, December 29, 2008 19:36:36
i feel it's not so much of the fear for the muslims but to flex muscles and to be a bully towards others. Just like the use of Allah. Just look at the way things are being done...just because there is a 60% does not mean that there is 100%. Hawker ctrs, stalls at govt complexs, highway rest areas, employment in govt sector, GLCs ...the list is long.....
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 11
...
written by ctm999, December 29, 2008 19:54:31
Sometimes we wonder why Christians, Jews and Muslims fight each other. We are after all believing in the same God. How can we be otherwise when we all believe in Abraham and the God Abraham believe in? The only difference is what we believe about God and the method to worship God. If the Bible is also about the same God, I wonder why Muslims should not treat it as alternative literature to know more about their God, our God. For I am a Quran reading Christian.
report abuse
disagree 4
agree 11
...
written by KetamPadang, December 29, 2008 20:23:05
I think God protects His followers.
God protect His religion.
God is Great.
He is God our Mighty God.
God said He is our defender.

Why should followers protect God?
Why should any religious bodies protect its God.
Is our God weak that He need our protection?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 14
...
written by lovemalaysiarakyat, December 29, 2008 20:57:21
I was so glad to have an English translation of the Quran. I could read it and understand it. But why can't the bible be in Bahasa Melayu or is it Bahasa Malaysia? We can't even decide yet - Melayu or Malaysia?

The Bhahavagita was available in English and I enjoyed reading it as a student of the arts and social sciences. So rich in language and wisdom. What is wrong with having translations. If by reading another's holy book and one can be converted then that Holy Book must be something, right?

We don't need to protect Islam, it should be able to protect itself. The one and only true God over the universe knows how to protect Himself too. Let us have our own will and choice. It makes more committed followers.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 15
...
written by cllim123, December 29, 2008 21:50:09
I have read the Bible many times and I still am not converted to being a Christian. Not that I am saying there is anything wrong with Christianity but that by reading it alone cannot so easily convert anyone.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 12
...
written by alpha100, December 29, 2008 23:43:39
Yes, i guess authority is right in not allowing Bible to be in bahasa! The truth may hurt!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 5
...
written by johanssm, December 30, 2008 05:52:09
If a simple and clear cut case of Lina Joy they do not wants to resolves .What is there to explain and persuade the gov. to have the Bible in the malay language?
Yes, they are afraid if Lina Joy gets what she wanted the entire "ketuanan" will fumbles and tumbles.
I can be very frank with anyone . My grandfather and my father are both muslims.
While i am a Buddhist my brother is a Christian. What went wrong?
Nothing went wrong. We chose our own path. It is my path, why you worry?
Give Lina Joy her freedom and unblocks religious books in the malay language.We will have less things to bickers.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 3
...
written by johanssm, December 30, 2008 05:59:07
I might gets into trouble writing like this.
Still it is my path and nothing can changes anything.
Books can be in any language, even in sign language (visual) but you cannot change believes , God or teachings and way of nature.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by RumahPanjai, December 30, 2008 07:20:32
Indonesian with ten times as many muslims has the bible in bahasa indonesia. In Malaysia, the government don't even trust the muslim malay race. This government treats the malays like idiots who don't have a mind to think for themselves. The muslims here have to be spoon fed? How degrading! The government is playing god.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 7
...
written by Sabahfan, December 30, 2008 21:32:57
As i said, only insecure religious leaders are afreaid of competition...

the only way they can survive is force their brand of religion to all the people of the world.... SHAME... and proof that their religion is BULSSHIT
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 1
...
written by Davy McChester, December 31, 2008 00:17:44
Try bringing non Islamic religious texts into Saudi Arabia ? The morons would throw them into the rubbish bin at the entry point. So much for freedom of religion from the "guardians"(or despots) of Islam.They fear for their future what alternate thoughts based on the age of reasoning can do to them.They would rather have monotheism and spew hatred to maintain their status quo. They need a permanent enemy for eternity,otherwise they would become the targets for Muslim awakening.To make it work in Malaysia what Farouk A. Peru is talking about,you have to look beyond Arab imperialism
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by hischildanba, January 01, 2009 12:49:57
The worlds largest muslim country Indonesia has Bible's in Bahasa Indonesia and the worlds second largest muslim populated nation India has Bibles in many languages, the world's third largest muslim country, Pakistan has Bibles in Urdu. I wonder what we are afraid of?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by amoker, January 02, 2009 13:51:07
Home Minister has also banned the BM pages of the Catholic Herald in their latest, last minute permit renewal. Very consistent with this myopic view.

No BM bible, so we use Bahasa Indonesia loh... kakah. Nobody can stop the people from reading. The same with the herald thing. But the decision borders on stupidity for those who are schooled to use BM as the lingua franca.

I read Quran in English and have never been more sure of what I read in the bible. Seemed that many Christians are reading the quran as well. very good.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
 
Some Images Hosted With
Thank You ImageShack!
 BLOGGERS AGAINST ISA

Powered and Optimized for:
Malaysia Today by MT-TEAM