A+ | A- | Reset
Home arrow The Blogs arrow Letters/Surat arrow The Indicators of Doom

The Indicators of Doom PDF Print
Wednesday, 17 December 2008 17:03
When the leaders of this country along with the local top economic advisors say that this great nation of ours is immune to the global economic meltdown brought about by an international credit crunch, do you believe them? Or do you believe the volumes of foreign news from all around the world spelling out economic Armageddon in bold on their front pages?

Why don’t we look at this from a different aspect and try to understand who is saying why and when about what is actually happening and whose truth does one believe in. There are certain indicators that do not lie and gold is one of them.

Gold is a metal commodity that is revered since God-Knows-When and it is traded around the world today as one of the most important physical element. One can own it and feel it in one’s hands. One can use it for coinage, jewellery or in electronics parts. Gold is also traded on the spot and futures markets globally and it was once used as a standard, being pegged by a nation’s currency. So, what is actually gold? What makes it so valuable? Why the human obsession?

 

The price of an item is driven by the supply and demand factors. When supply is low and demand is high, the price skyrockets. Alternately, when supply is a plentiful and demand is weak, the price bottoms out. This is an economic certainty. Gold however is different. It retains its intrinsic value regardless of whether the supply and demand is evident or otherwise. The only other commodity having such inherent characteristics is oil. That is why oil is also known as “black gold”. Herein lies the dilemma.

When Citicorp, the largest banking institution in the entire history of the world, is in dire straits and requiring a government bailout, one can say that the global economic shit has hit the fan, big time. Credit crunch. What the Hell is a credit crunch? Well, insofar as I know, it is the deprivation of credit and without credit (owing to whatever factors) there is no trade. A company that cannot do trading is a dormant company. A nation that cannot do trading becomes a banana republic. Hyperinflation sets in as the value of its currency becomes insignificant. Prices for everything (goods and services) shoot up and the overall value of a nation decreases. Savings and pension funds are devalued and all banking institutions take a massive wallop. Share prices will be non-indicative of its true value and will render a nation’s economy worthless.

So what has this to do with gold? Gold is traded in US Dollars (so is black gold). When the value of greenbacks depreciates against all currencies, gold would hereafter be traded at a lesser value than what it is actually worth. The price of gold (and black gold) will (one would think) henceforth rise to offset this devalued dollar. Well, this has not happened. The prices of gold and black gold have actually dropped, rather drastically too. Okay, one anomaly does not indicate a global economic meltdown.

Let us now look at the futures prices for gold. Gold futures for January and February 2009 are, mildly said, bleak. When a commodity’s spot price is higher than the following delivery month’s futures price, it means that the value of that particular commodity is dropping. No big deal as the value of gold has always automatically corrected itself. When the following month’s futures price is also higher than the next following month’s futures prices, the economists call it “backwardation”. In the entire history of the world, gold has never experienced a backwardation, until December 2008. In fact, gold futures have never experienced a fall in price (and worth) for more than one single trading day and certainly never ever trickled across the following delivery month. Now we are looking at a minimum of three months’ drop in prices (since the 1st of December). This means that the gold basis has turned negative. Anomaly number two. Same with black gold – anomaly number three.

What is exactly the gold basis? The gold basis is an incorruptible measure of trust in paper money. During the “Gold-Standard” Great Depression years of Roosevelt, the US Dollar was backed by physical gold. Not anymore since 1971 when it was allowed to float in the international trading markets. All currencies are now operated on a system called the “fiat money” which can be defined as “money that is intrinsically irredeemable and is primarily utilized only as a medium of exchange”, hence the gold basis as an indicative backing system for a currency’s actual worth.

When the gold basis turns negative, the confidence and trust accorded the value of currencies drop. Paradoxically, one US Dollar now is not worth one US Dollar of before. When this happens, hyperinflation sets in. A loaf of bread costing US 1 Dollar might cost US 10 Dollars now. Where does the additional US 9 Dollars come from? Credit, what credit? Remember that there is a credit crunch?

And then there are the paper gold traders and bullion banks. Gold can also be traded in paper form whereby the issuers guarantee the buyers ala traders ala investors, the value of gold on a piece of paper or in a “gold account”. In Malaysia, certain major banks offer such services. The government guarantees bank depositors their Ringgit but not investors. Likewise, the banks guarantee the value of the investment, not the worth. If ever the international bullion banks go bankrupt (either fraudulently or through the depreciation of the US Dollar against the value of gold), the investment will turn sour. This is quite possible if the price of gold continues to drop. In a backwardation scenario, spot gold traders will not continue to trade as gold producers stop production and go into hibernation. Futures gold traders holding these contracts will be wiped out as there can be no deliveries of this commodity and their contracts give them no right to physical gold anyway. Since there will be no legal trading of gold, all legal protection of the ownership of and trade in gold will be suspended indefinitely.

This is altogether only hypothetical but in reality quite feasible. How will it affect Malaysia? The Ringgit is also an irredeemable “fiat” currency and not backed by any physical form of gold, and irredeemable currency can last only as long as it is visibly capable of supporting the futures market(s) in gold. Without a futures market trading gold, “wherefore art thou, my Malaysian Ringgit?”

Yes, the southeastern nations of Asia (except Vietnam and Indonesia) are not directly affected by the depressing economic downturn as being experienced now in America and Europe. Part of the reasons why is due to our de-leveraged banking institutions and the high amount of foreign currencies currently being held by the respective governments here. Inadvertently though, the effects of the larger American and European markets will trickle down here and Malaysia will not be immune to it. This is because the Malaysian economy together with all the southeastern nations’ economies added together are not large enough to sustain this corner of the earth irrespective of the massive American and European markets. No matter what the government does here to try to stimulate the local economy, the greater effects from America and Europe will eclipse all attempts to divert this global economic tsunami away from our shores.

You can bet your last “irredeemable” ringgit on it. Better still; bet your last ringgit on the Indian economy because India is the only country left in the entire world enjoying a positive economic growth rate.

- Hakim Joe

Comments (16)Add Comment
...
written by alpha100, December 17, 2008 17:16:32
Well! Under the current situation where doom is booming, better to believe them with pince of salt! Cos this goverment is I believe still going to be around for next 4 years plus. So let's just believe and pray for best cos they is nothing much we can do except tighten our belts to lessen the burden what come may!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 11
...
written by ahmadneil, December 17, 2008 17:21:28
Better to join those deep sea fishermen who don't have to make a living catching fish but selling diesel in the high seas.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 32
...
written by ctchoolaw, December 17, 2008 17:23:22
The idea of reverting to the gold standard is compelling. But this is a concept that may take decades to take root, if at all. There is a clear addiction to unilateral printing of currency by every central bank. It is impossible to go "cold turkey" from this monetary fix. In the mean time we will have economic challenges aplenty. Despite what the govt says, Malaysians are doing the right thing to be fiscally prudent. Wanton spending is a silly risk to take for the humble wage earner. http://ctchoolaw.********.com/
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 6
...
written by Lembing, December 17, 2008 17:23:24
HAKIM JOE

I just wonder which source(s) did you get your statistics from.
India, the only ecomony with positive ecomonic growth rate????? I doubt this.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 11
..., Lowly rated comment [Show]
...
written by *********, December 17, 2008 18:00:03
After all, the corrupt regimes that rule ASEAN and especially China themselves are committing gross human rights abuses against it's own citizens. China's top oil producer China National Petroleum Corporation are among companies giving much-needed income to Myanmar, defying activists' calls to pull out. "China and Thailand are the major buyers of teak and jade. They just want short-term business interests. They don't care about the lives of Burmese people," said Aung Thu Nyein, a Thai-based Myanmar analyst. Japan's Nippon Oil Corp., South Korean's Daewoo International, Malaysia's state-run energy firm Petronas, as well as two Indian power giants, Gail India and Oil and Natural Gas Corp., are also jockeying for billion-dollar contracts...More http://*********.********.com
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by cheekhiaw, December 17, 2008 18:10:59
Gold backwardation happens when the spot (today's) price of gold is higher than its future or forward price. In layman speak, that means gold for immediate delivery is higher than gold for delivery in the future.

Theoretically, when than happens any smart owner of gold would sell his gold 'in hand' and go into a contract with another guy to buy it back later at a lower price and make a handsome profit. If that happens the 'arbitrage' window would be closed and backwardation would end.

But the fact that gold backwardation is persisting i.e. no one is going after that 'good deal' is telling us that owners with 'gold in hand' are not parting with their holdings no matter how good a deal others are offering to entice him to part with his gold now and get that gold back IN THE FUTURE with profits.

That is because holders of gold have no trust that if they part with their gold now they would ever see that gold again later even if others 'promise' him a handsome profit! Gold in hand is real asset. The promise to receive gold is not.

'With so many crooks around, don't part with what you have in hand no matter what the future promise is' is the position.

Just like Che Det's Vision 2020 and many other things peole of his type peddle. A promise from people you don't trust is no use. Better keep what you have in hand.

The same 'educational backwardation' may also be happening with the DJZ fellas's response to the latest 'idea' being sold by some idiots that used to wave crooked knives.

xxx
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by cheekhiaw, December 17, 2008 18:19:44
dragonheart,

You believe in what Che Det peddle?

If he believed in backing paper money with real value he does not need to wait for a gold dinar to do it. He only has to benchmark his MYR to the price of a basket of goods or assets including gold. That means managing inflation.

What does his actual record the last 30 years says about that?

Look at the USD/MYR exchange rate over 30 years. Even as the US is printing monopoly money, the MYR got lower and lower against that cheat currency. That means Che Det was cheating more than uncle sam!

A thief promising you a better future while he steals from you, you also believe. What sort of backwardation is that?

xxx
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 14
...
written by foresight, December 17, 2008 19:16:47
Hakim Joe,
Your last statement is not quite right.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by lynn, December 17, 2008 19:26:42
Imagine a new govt of Malaysia seized all ill-gotten stolen wealth from the corrupt politicians, past and present. And distribute the wealth back to the rakyat.

In Malaysia, from what I hear, it's hard to recover stolen stuff. Once gone, gone forever.

report abuse
disagree 0
agree 7
...
written by Xrap11, December 17, 2008 20:48:28
Hakim,
Not sure where are you heading with this. Minus the last paragraph, quite an interesting article. USD still tha backbone of international trading. To move away require unity, like Euro,nevetherless still papers. Gold Dinars would require middle east support and unity of islamic country for a start. Boleh ka? Middle easter still very much happy to trade their oil with USD. Paper bill forever bro. Jangan jadi Zimbabwe sudah.
http://gelamapisang.********.com
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by Just Gan, December 17, 2008 22:30:07
There is no need to really worry. If the global financial crisis hits Malaysia, the country can implement currency control as it did in 1998. If the country could implement currency control in 1998, when its foreign reserves were practically depeleted, and succeed , the country can certainly weather any financial challenge today by implementing curency control again but, this time, backed by the billions of US$ reserve. Unless of course the currency control of 1998 had a lot more happening which we do not know about. In any case, if Malaysia does get into financial trouble, the govt. can once again ask Mahathir to do his magic.
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 2
...
written by onnetline, December 18, 2008 01:16:22
When the Prime Minister & his cronies are not honest people, what else can you expect ?
More lies only, right ?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 6
...
written by Hakim Joe, December 18, 2008 15:12:23
Hi foresight and Xrap. The last statement is entirely my hypothesis. I am actually assisting a friend of mine prepare his MBA thesis and did a lot of research on it and all silent indicators exhibit as a fact that the Indian economy will utilise this economic slowdown to increase their international market share. The ASEAN countries are following suit but this particular market is not large enuf to start and sustain an economic boom. In Asia, China, South Korea and Japan are completely out of the picture because their economies are tied to US. Latin America, Eastern and Western Europe is in the same boat. Africa is not even in the picture. That leaves India and the Middle East nations. However said, where are the petrol dollars going to be invested in? The finger points to India and southeast Asia.

I am also in the midst of writing another letter on this topic but it is 50:50 that MT will publish it cos it is an economic research paper and MT is not an economic forum.

Cheers! Thanks for the input!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by Susanna, December 19, 2008 09:21:51
Our leaders are making a mockery of themselves. Even housewives and taxi drivers are aware of impending trouble. With leaders who are fooling themselves and trying to kid us too, alamak we certainly are going to shipwreck!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by lynn, December 19, 2008 14:11:08
Actually these so-called "leaders" of this bodohland are speaking for themselves. There is no crisis for them personally.


They own tens, hundreds of millions and billions, how wud this financial crisis affect them or family?

It doesn't. I have a few friends who are multi-millionaires, they brushed aside all these news abt economic crisis like brushing off dust. They are up to their eyeballs in cash.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
 
Some Images Hosted With
Thank You ImageShack!
 BLOGGERS AGAINST ISA

Powered and Optimized for:
Malaysia Today by MT-TEAM