A+ | A- | Reset
Home arrow The Blogs arrow Letters/Surat arrow Pakatan’s 3 front War

Pakatan’s 3 front War PDF Print
Friday, 05 December 2008 15:33
One, it is a war of attrition against BN; Two, it is another war to keep the supporters involved until the next federal elections; and Three, it is a war between the factions making up the Pakatan Rakyat coalition. Three simultaneous battles to secure the rights to form the next federal government.

Not an easy undertaking for any person aspiring to be the next Prime Minister of Malaysia. Can Anwar Ibrahim be that particular person to assume the responsibilities that has befallen him? This is not a brief task as the next federal election is slotted before 2013. That is four very long years and anything can happen within this period of time. Additionally, there is the threat of a sodomy case against him together with an “all-too-evident” DNA Bill bubbling in the works (even though it has been deferred to next year which is a month away). If this is not sufficient to cause major anxiety to the aspiring PM, there are the in fighting between PAS and DAP on several fronts that has grabbed the headline news in the local media.

As Malaysia Day has come to pass with only a hint of a whisper, the disillusionment of the Pakatan supporters have been tempered by the conduct in which the BN government has manipulated the course of event to be apparently non-functional with its impromptu sending of certain politicians to Taiwan for a brief period of time. Pakatan can sincerely be thankful to BN for doing so because it provides them with a valid alibi as to why the thirty BN legislators did not crossover to PR, as assured by DSAI. Frankly speaking, it was never going to happen at that particular date as Parliament was out of session. Secondly, the dilemma of having a large number of “non-Malay” elected legislators crossing over to PR is not what DSAI and PR envisioned owing to the fact that it would disturb the balance of power within this multiracial party. PAS will never stand for it, as it will undermine the Ketuanan Melayu concept while voicing out that they are impartial to racial hegemony. In fact certain PKR legislators will be aghast at this, if ever it happened (which it did not). Even the majority of Malaysian Malays will be revolted if ever this comes to pass.

The truth of the matter is that DSAI has intentionally guided its supporters to assume that the crossovers are made up of parliamentarians from East Malaysia but a lot of Pakatan’s supporters can evidently deduce that this is purely a façade to divert the BN government from the real “jumpers”. I truthfully believe that the seventeen or so parliamentarians (on the “list”) that had verbally agreed to cross over are in fact from BN component parties in West Malaysia, especially UMNO. This agreement was made when BN was backpedaling, before Malaysia Day. All bets are off now when DSAI was incapable of garnering sufficient BN parliamentarians to consent to jumping over. As for the East Malaysian “decoy”, the stronger BN component parties from Sabah and Sarawak will never agree to jump unless the figure “30” is brought down to less than ten. If this becomes a reality, they become the powerful Kingmaker and in the process secure the real power behind the throne. Not a scenario DSAI (and PKR) envisaged and certainly not a situation both PAS and DAP desires, not even to form the government. The only jumper has not joined PR but stayed as an independent party when the supposedly cascade did not materialize.

As the attempts to tempt such crossovers are being extended to an undeclared date, BN has begun to consolidate and from their defensive stance of Pak Lah’s regime, they have started the grand offensive to deny Pakatan any such opportunities by the enticing of PR parliamentarians to leave the opposition camp. In achieving so (even with just a few), BN would have effectively demoralized both the opposition supporters and the opposition party members. A grand ploy indeed.

DSAI has no reasons to be afraid of being incarcerated for the alleged sodomy charges because the government will not be enthusiastic to make a martyr out of him. What BN will do is to ridicule and demean DSAI until his popularity and integrity are being questioned by his PR colleagues and his band of supporters. Only then will they move in for the kill, once and for all, and this time the outcry will resemble a whimper that will be overwhelmed by a massive show of force by BN. Another ten years behind bars will effectively condemn DSAI to obscurity and turn the nation to an autocratic state.

It is henceforth imperative that DSAI gathers all his forces to conduct an enormous push towards Putrajaya. The future of Malaysia depends on it.

- Hakim Joe

Comments (10)Add Comment
...
written by ibabonma, December 05, 2008 16:01:54
I am optimistic and believing in the reality that once an UMNO-you listen to Anwar’s speech, you are an Anwarista by conscription and there is no turning back to UMNO.
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 13
...
written by ahmadneil, December 05, 2008 17:02:43
The CHANGE we all have been waiting is just round the corner.With another crushing blow to umno in this coming by-election in Terengganu,it will sent shivers down their spine.This by-election will decide the fate of Najis.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 16
...
written by The dragonheart, December 05, 2008 17:30:42
I believe in democracy. Jumping seats from one party to another doesn't seem right.

These MPs were voted by the people and they shouldn't betray the voters who vote for them. If they do, then definitely there will be unrest among the people. and in the next election the people will not vote for him anymore.

PR should start educating younger potential voters and existing voters to vote for them in the next GE rather than asking MPs to cheat their voters. You won't last long this way.

In winning politics there is one simple rule to follow... it is not about how good you are but it is about how many people can you get to vote for you...

Remember, Rome was never build in one day...
report abuse
disagree 6
agree 6
...
written by Proarte, December 05, 2008 20:17:42

This election is not about the merits of 'local democracy' over a 'parachute' candidate. It is about a turf war in PAS of the 'progressives' over the 'Hadi' faction and the future of the Pakatan alliance. The idea that a local 'Pak Kadok' is preferable to a charismatic PAS leader of huge popularity on the ground such as Mat Sabu is plainly ridiculous.

UMNO would love to have an opposition 'Pak Kadok' in parliament. Mat Sabu instead will give make them decidedly uneasy. Let us remind ourselves if we did not have 'parachute' candidates, we would not have DAP as the state government in Penang or Kit Siang as MP for Ipoh Timur.

When we have the 'conservative' wing in PAS showing their Taliban tendencies and their turncoat behaviour towards 'Pakatan' by willing to do deals with UMNO, it would be stupid to support their candidate. If Mat Sabu is not selected it would mean a victory for the 'ulamak' wing and this will mean the impossibility of a viable Pakatan.

PAS at the best of times is a stumbling block to a viable coalition because of its Islamic State ambitions and atavistic world view. It is fair to say that DAP and PAS have disparate ideologies. There is also distrust of PAS within the DAP and PKR ranks over their commitment to the democratic process and 'Ketuanan Rakyat'. Hadi did openly say that PAS would not support Pakatan if Muslims were not 'dominant' in the coalition. DAP and PKR have openly rejected racism and religious bigotry and made that a central platform of their political convictions.

There are honest and sincere politicians in PAS and they are mostly aligned to the 'progressive' wing of PAS and include Mat Sabu, Husam Musa , Dr Dzulkifli Ahmad etc. If there is any chance of Pakatan being viable then we have to witness the ascendency of this camp in PAS.

Mat Sabu may not be a 'local' but he is a high profile PAS figure. He may be only an ITM graduate with a folksy and simpleton manner, but he is an intellectual with great humanity. He is deeply religious but a self confessed 'liberal'. He oratorical skills are legendary and he is widely popular on the ground.

Remember even a 'giant' local like Hadi Awang was booted out ignominiousy in the 2004 parliamentary elections. Sabu only lost by a whisker in 2008. His broad appeal and close friendship which he has with Guan Eng and Karpal of DAP will be helpful in getting Chinese support who are the King makers in this election.

Do not expect DAP to lend their support to PAS in this election if Mat Sabu is rejected. It will portend the direction in which PAS is heading and ultimately affect the viability of this loose coalition known as 'Pakatan'.

There is more than meets the eye in this election
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 6
...
written by Motherchell, December 05, 2008 21:22:59
There are so many similarities between MUGABE and UMNO Leaders. ---The abuse , the traits , the tricks , the greed for power and many more !!

We have an Albozo who always says its the "LER" that all have to follow -- borrowing the pronunciation from Inspector Clouseau .

Truth and Justice will win in the end! UMNO will soon be history!

http://sjsandteam.*********.com
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by hckit, December 05, 2008 22:00:36
4 years is not long to wait BUT it's too much time for our wealth to be stolen by devil and evil of BN/UMNOs.

More Majlis Perbandaran will be bankrupt.
More lands will be sold cheaply.
More gift and commission will be taken.
More helicopters will be bought
and etc.


report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by binarytan, December 05, 2008 23:04:54
Sorry proarte, if I were DAP I will also not going to help in this election should Mat Sabu is rejected by PAS.

I think same to Chinese society 11% there.

PAS is thinking very high and speaking lots of nonsence on ketuanan islam. They think Islam is the only religion in the world, too sad this is the truth. Also they think they are the best in the world after holding 3 states MB.

Previously, Nik is working hard to remain the image of PAS. Seems like it is being damaged by a group of UMNO type of evils, with full of racist people, singing the song of ketuanan islam and marginalize non muslim.

Dont believe, what happen to PKNS non muslim boss and 50% quota in Kedah.

It is better not to set everything with quota just like NEP system, idiot PAS.

But I believe PAS will win in KT by election, UMNO just too problematic and more volatile.

smilies/angry.gif smilies/angry.gif smilies/angry.gif
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 2
...
written by nana tanjung, December 06, 2008 00:21:39
ProArte & FlexTan,
When it comes to Malay politics, esp. east coats rural and semi rural politics, you're no more than Primary One students.

I like Mat Sabu as well. We need him in the parliament. But winnability always take precedent. The local psyche does not say Mat Sabu is the most winnable candidate; so what use do PAS put him.

Malays in this country is a big community, not like Indian (with mere 9%) or Chinese with some 27% of the total population.There are almost 65% of the population.

Malays in urban areas like KL or Seberang Perai are more receptive to the any candidate proposed by PAS or PKR. Malays in Penang island are still largely UMNO. Malays in Kelantan or Kedah are very open in accepting outsiders as election candidates. But try that to the more sentimental Malays in states like Johor or Trengganu. Perhaps the only common thing to Malays at large is that we are still very much pessimistic towards DAP.

At a more macro level, please understand again, as much as you'd like to dream, PAS doesn't give a damn to what you think. You can rave and rant as you like. But those who will deliver the votes are the people of the constituency being contest. so any candidates, policies and statements aree aimed at pleasing this target group. You're not the target group.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Proarte, December 06, 2008 01:14:33
Nana said:

"PAS doesn't give a damn to what you think. You can rave and rant as you like. But those who will deliver the votes are the people of the constituency being contest. so any candidates, policies and statements aree aimed at pleasing this target group."


What can a local 'Pak Kadok' do for the people of Terengganu? By your argument it is better to vote in UMNO. But then that is exactly what the 'Hadi faction' of PAS wants. They would rather UMNO win rather than see Mat Sabu win. It is not about winnability. That is just patent nonsense. There is a turf war going on and this will determine the future direction of PAS and the viability of Pakatan.

Nana seems to have an infantile understanding of PAS politics.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by renoir, December 07, 2008 07:57:00
ProArte's take on the turf war and the psychology of the Hadi faction is cogent and realistic. The fate of Pakatan on the choice of a PAS candidate is indeed at stake. The presence of UMNO clones in PKR too is a worry, especially when they're still up and about with their exclusive BTN-inspired language of bangsa, agama and negara. Still, I'm happy that DAP is taking things as they come and willing to help in KT. Keep the eyes on the prize - a better country - but be prepared to face more shocks from extremists in the opposition alliance.

May the progressive PAS faction wins at KT!

LChuah
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 0

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
 

Sponsored Links

World Futures  Moscow's Middle East conference: Should the Muslims depend only on the US to solve the Palestine crisis?

Future Fastforward  A controversial analysis by a controversial analyst, Matthias Chang, the lawyer-writer who unabashedly calls a spade a spade and offers no apology for doing so.

Internet TV 3000+ Channels  Pick your favorite internet TV channels straight to your PC! Yay!

Some Images Hosted With
Thank You ImageShack!
 BLOGGERS AGAINST ISA

Powered and Optimized for:
Malaysia Today by MT-TEAM