A+ | A- | Reset
Home

Merits of one school system PDF Print
Posted by admin   
Friday, 05 December 2008 11:11

(The Sun) THE call to unify all the school systems by Datuk Mukhriz Mahathir is possibly the most important step in overcoming the ever growing racial divide among Malaysians. By putting together the future generation of Malaysia under one school roof, we are taking the first step in national unity: allowing them to socialise and experience racial diversity when young.

I’m appalled at how almost all our shortsighted politicians talk of the "importance of multiple education systems" and evade the issue at hand. Mukhriz did not suggest removing the different systems of education. He suggested unifying all the different schools under one system with multiple choices of education still available.

I have been through two education systems, the first being a reputable private school, dominated by Chinese, and the second was a standard government primary school. Now on hindsight, I can proudly say that the greatest educational experience in my life came from the government school where I was exposed to different cultures and religions. It took much difficulty and time for me to adapt to the new environment of diverse mix of cultures, but it was all worth it as it taught me the important lessons of tolerance and understanding, of how different people think differently and to be more open minded and accept different opinions.

Based on my experience, I find those who have studied in vernacular schools to be the least tolerant. I find most people I encounter from such schooling have closed mindsets and difficulty accepting people with different ideas and thoughts. People who have been kept in an education system where they only mix with those of similar thinking and lacking exposure to people from different cultures.

And the evidence is clear to see, just count how many are successful in migrating and living in distant countries and cultures other than their "homeland". It’s this form of "birds of a feather" mentality that the idea of "racism" stems from: The lack of tolerance and openness to different thoughts and ideas.

Another issue is the common excuse used in the political arena: claiming that this would remove our "cultural diversity" by refusing the teaching of "mother tongue". The education system’s one and only purpose is to impart knowledge and skills to our future generation to prepare them to be useful members of society. The imparting of culture and "mother tongue" should never be the sole responsibility of the system. The responsibility should mostly lie with the child’s family. At most the system could allow for choices in what language education could be provided, at the parents and student’s discretion but all under one system and under one roof. Look at the way our schools are built: separate school buildings, separate compounds, separate administrations, all built for separate "races" and cultures. How do you expect our children to not be instilled with racial and segregated mentalities? How can we expect racial unity if our own children are brought up in schools that look as divided as East and West Berlin were?

This is Malaysia.

This country is a mosaic of different cultures and people. If we as Malaysians are to stand united, compromises have to be made on all sides. Every culture, every "race", everyone has to make small sacrifices. It is something Malaysia has to undergo to be a unified, mature and responsible nation. Diversity is our country’s true identity. Unless we strive to control and tap our diversity to achieve our nation’s goals, it will be its greatest curse rather than its greatest asset.

Benjamin Wong
Cyberjaya

Comments (39)Add Comment
...
written by techgeek, December 05, 2008 11:21:15
This is bullshit. The problem lies with our racially segregated political system and all the racist policies our BN government comes up with. Kids aren't rascist; they have no problems playing, studying, mixing with other kids from other races. However, the problem starts when they grow up. "Oh, UiTM? That's for Malays". "I'm sorry you can't qualify for Medicine; that's reserved for Malays. Here, you can go study forestry". And other crap like that. What do you expect? Of course our children turn out the way WE are now - racially polarised!

Wake up, you blithering idiots!
report abuse
disagree 15
agree 49
...
written by POTH, December 05, 2008 11:46:05
The only remedy is to get the BeNd out of power then only we talk about changing any system. When one have a interest at stack do you think they will let go they grip in the system? Why Mr Zaid was sack from his party? Aren't they all coming from the same system? It all boils down to financial gains only. Money, money, money nothing but money.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 19
...
written by Oscar Winner, December 05, 2008 11:46:20
What good is our school system?? You sometimes wonder what UMNO goons learned in school. They will never know what CONSCIENCE is… All UMNO goons learnt in school was CON-science
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 14
...
written by AO Musa, December 05, 2008 11:55:59
It’s really amusing when Indian & Chinese are championing about getting equal rights for every race but they just can’t accept the idea of having single race school.

I’m not BN supporter but I definitely support this suggestion. It’s takes at least 2 generations to have fully interracial community. But if we don’t make any move now, we will not achieve this forever. I only see benefit from this suggestion.
report abuse
disagree 23
agree 27
...
written by Rock, December 05, 2008 12:09:56
I am a product of multi-racial govt school i.e ACS Klang and RMC. Before i was in all malay primary school. I think i learned alot of being malaysian whan i was in the two learning institutions. I believed we should foster more efforts to ensure that students were given chance to study in those kinds of school.
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 11
...
written by ToeJam, December 05, 2008 12:13:10
Hi Musa,
It’s really amusing that you cannot understand the concerns of the Indian & Chinese community. If you can bring yourself out of your comfort zone and put yourself in their shoes, perhaps you will find that it's not a very amusing issue after all.

Yes our indian and chinese friends want equal rights for every race but they just can’t accept the idea of having single race school because they strongly suspect they will get a rotten deal in the long run. go and hear what RPK explained how this govt in 1960's hijacked ISA till now after tricking everyone that ISA is only to fight communists and it is meant for the good of the country. you may realised these communities concerns are valid and not so amusing. Think of NEP. If the govt are serious then do the first gesture; open UiTM to all and then we will believe that the govt has good intentions.
report abuse
disagree 5
agree 25
..., Lowly rated comment [Show]
...
written by borneoman, December 05, 2008 12:28:54
i concur with you techgeek.umno led bn use education as their tools to 'melayunize' malaysians because they think they are the superior race just like the nazi aryans and to keep other races at bay so that their special tuan positions will not be challenged. malayu study agama islam others study tuan melayu umno styled moral,bahasa melayu,sejarah agama islam.indirectly they are telling us that their agama is more official than ours.
benjamin wong,
do you think the malaysian ministry of education will allow non muslim to study their own respective religion in government school as a formal subject like their malay counterpart with their matapelajaran agama islam?
are you sure you are not building castle in the air mr benjamin?
Another issue is the common excuse used in the political arena: claiming that this would remove our "cultural diversity" by refusing the teaching of "mother tongue". The education system’s one and only purpose is to impart knowledge and skills to our future generation to prepare them to be useful members of society. The imparting of culture and "mother tongue" should never be the sole responsibility of the system. The responsibility should mostly lie with the child’s family.
you have no right to say that only certain "mother tongue "are more official than the others what knowledge and skills are you talking about?do you know in details the contents of the syllabus of certain subjects in school especially history and moral study?look very carefully at the hidden agenda in the whole system. differentiate between"yang tersurat and yang tersirat".
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 13
...
written by Malaysiaputra, December 05, 2008 12:43:05
Benjamin Wong, Umno has succeeded in brainwashing you. Do you think if you can speak only Malay in your family, your children can get to buy houses with 10% discount?, get into Uitm ?, get into the metriculasi course ?, get special loan for bumi ?

Forget it man. Only way is if you marry a Malay wife, and renounce your Chinese ancestry then your children will be considered Malay then you join Umno , then they will tell you, you are in unity with them.
report abuse
disagree 9
agree 27
...
written by InEffective, December 05, 2008 12:48:57

Unity-by-Coercion vs Unity-by-Equality

The above captures the undeveloped mind that believes that language buys unity. Social stupidity seems to have no limits in Malaysia.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by SimpleSoul, December 05, 2008 12:55:03
Dear Benjamin,
While i may agree to the certain point i also beg to differ. A survey was done in the states, when a group of academicians studied the behavioural pattern of kids.

Age group of 3-10 = all races with and played well.
Age group of 10-17= they all mix and played with individual ethnic group.

Blacks grouped with blacks, whites with themselves and asians as well. it was not the kid who became racist But it was their parents and system they had.

So let me ask you, what the use of intergrating children now? and when they grow up they are exposed to UMNO, MCA and MIC calls? That the parties should be race based? Why dont u get BN to fully merge and despise race based politics, Then only u can have a 1 system school. Until then let the UMNO become rich and other swindle for themselves.
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 12
...
written by ssathia, December 05, 2008 12:55:27
How do you promote one national culture? In an one hour of cultural show, show 58 minutes of Malay dance, one minute each for Chinese and Indian dances.

How do you prepare one five year plan? Write a 5000 page report, and include the words Chinese and Indians twice, while the rest talk about Bumiputras.

How do you create one coalition government? Grab as many ministerial posts as possible and then grudingly grant one post to Indians and increasingly fewer posts to Chinese subject to towing the line.

How do you create national budget? Collect major tax money from Chinese and Indians and give most of it to Bumiputras to build mosques and Malays only educational institutes. Then urge to close down Tamil and Chinese schools.

How do recruit government servants, police and military? Recruit all Malays and blame non-Malays for not applying.

How do you create a progressive Malaysia? By abolishing Tamil and Chinese schools promising to teach all these under one roof but pay lip service like the thousands of schools do in Malaysia when it comes to pupils' own language. Produce Indian and Chinese graduates illiterate in English and in their own mother tongue. That is the surest way to eleminate competition.

Those are the slogans as could be seen in the many arguments of the pseudo intellectuals of this country. Does it make you wonder whether they are they national or anti-national elements?
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 40
...
written by Democrats, December 05, 2008 13:06:24
Agree with the author that we need to revamp the education system like murkriz said. However he could have worded it better, using "that the one school system COULD help improve racial integration" rather than making it the main reason for racial divide the justification that is it the only solution on address the issue of racial polarization. knowing damn well all the other policys in the government from contract and scolarship award, admission into universities, exclusive discounts, etc....

As for the UMNO bashing, it is only happening through backlash of what has been dished out.

Lim Kit Siang is right when it is mention that it is seditious as it is stated in our constitution on the rights to education. But shouldn't we have the right to talk about it if we think it can be improved or help our country?

There in lies the problem, many feel the malay special rights are actually doing more harm than good and the elimination of it would not only foster greater racial integration and improve the overall livelihood of living standard of everyone, but if i do that or is mention by others, the get interogated by police or get held by the ISA. SO Lim Kit Siang is just pointing out the double standard, why don't police question him or him being held by ISA for "him own protection"?
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 5
...
written by ahmadneil, December 05, 2008 13:12:15
Repeat posting removed
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by wannabepatriotic, December 05, 2008 13:20:36
I must concur with the writer. i remember when i was in a government school (SRK Jalan Pasar) i played guli with the chinese, football with the malays and 'tikam' with the indian boys and getah with girls of any race. Indeed, i was color blind back then, and race has never been an issue. it's just whether we can ***** or not.

But now-a-days, finding kids hanging only with the same race in school/college is pathetic. I reckon the only time race is not an issue, is when they are online, behind a nickname with no clear indication of a/s/l/r(race) - this thanks to our racist government claiming to be non racist, but brandish a keris behind close doors.

It's not fair to bash vernacular schools, because you'll end up bashing the education system, education minister, etc. The malay, chinese, indians complain about losing 'their' mother tounge. If you ask me, we ought to have ENGLISH schools with Bahasa, Chinese & Tamil as ELECTIVES. Let the kids/parents decide on what they want to learn, already it's a known fact that many foresight parents are sending their kids to chinese schools. Why? Go ask them.

The education system will work once we have qualified teachers to teach our children. Just like jailing all our corrupted politicians, we'll also have to sack bus loads of teachers to get this done
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 18
...
written by myke, December 05, 2008 13:23:15
It all boils down to whether BN acan be trusted..If BN has people's trust, then the public has no problem agreeing to this. But we know that BN is the biggest liar, crook, slime ball and name everything bad thats what they are.

So NO PROBLEM GET IT DONE, but not with BN having the say in it. Let PR do it.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by picadilly, December 05, 2008 14:09:24
I was from a SRK/SMK and was a nobody until Reaching varsity and only then learnt the potential within me, The education system I didnt know shit about my mother tounge till went to varsity. Nobody gave a shit.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by mahkota, December 05, 2008 14:13:57
Totally agree with Democrats and wannabepatriotic. Integration at school level is only a small part in buiding unity. Without changes in higher education and public employmentment policies, this alone is useless. We need teachers with better quality, dedication and willingness to treat all students similarly regardless of the colour of their skin. But first of all, abolish Biro Tata Negara.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 10
...
written by AO Musa, December 05, 2008 14:32:01
Dear ToeJam,

I appreciate your view in this and please bear in mind, I haven't seen anyone been discriminated by our governing system like me or my siblings! Wondering why? I'm an Arab Indian mix offspring and basically I am not Malay neither Indian to Malaysia's system. Therefore I'm a no race man!

Government having problem to put me in one single race and they even went to the stage freezing my Amanah Saham account because they couldn't list me under Malay. Surprisingly, they allow me to open the account but now I cant withdraw a single cent until I prove to them that I am a Malay! Have you ever encountered such problem?

Now, when I go to Indian community they cant accept me because I have an Arab mother. You may have your MCA or MIC or Taoism/Buddhism society or even Hindu Sangam to support you. However, for me and my siblings, have to struggle our self for survival! Have your STPM certificate been held because they accidentally put you as Bumiputra? We had that experience!

Lack the mental capacity to understand what I mean ?


I totally don't see any necessity for you to write such comment. You may be the next Albert Einstein but please bear in mind not everyone as genius as you. Therefore, next time when you write in public blog, just keep to your self that there are 99.99% citizen out there (except you) who stupid enough and not at par to your knowledge.

Have a good day!
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 4
...
written by truthbespoken, December 05, 2008 15:06:10
Can't some of you guys out there get it out of your numbskulls? It is not so much as the non-Malays would want to object to a singular education system if they are confident that the teaching standards are qualitative and producing the required results..

To be blunt, they are not confident of the current system with Malay as medium of instruction and with the mass infusion of Islamic studies into the teaching system. The Chinese, perhaps Indians and even some Malays feel the current system is below par, below that of the Chinese medium schools, so how do you expect them to agree to the proposed change! How can this group be convinced there is sincerity in the proposal if there is any at all? Past records on policy changes, just like what Toejam said, are nothing to be proud of because the results mostly differ from its original intended purposes!

Don't be hookwinked again and again!. Unless there is absolute sincerity from the government-of-the-day to change for the betterment of all Malaysians where religious dogmaticism and racial parochialism are not contributing factors in the proposals for disagreements, then those proposals will not be worth its salt! The current government has yet to learn how to be more pragmatic when it comes to dealing with multi-racial concerns in the country! Issues like education will never be solved properly if not done sincerely for all.

It may not be a cure all but for starters, the government may want to consider an additional medium of instruction by re-introducing English teaching in some schools. Let's see how this old method of teaching develops from there. Change is done best when change is done naturally!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 9
...
written by OverseasMsian, December 05, 2008 15:48:36
My goodness. If we can't even agree our kids to be in the same scool, how can we be in same country?
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 5
...
written by Arubin, December 05, 2008 15:52:06
written by bogeyman, December 05, 2008 12:16:58
You commentors are only here to bash UMNO for anything that they do.... we are not talking about UmNO's racist policies here.... we are now talking about education system towards integration. Me? I've said it b4 in my posts and I'll say it again, get rid of vernacular schools, they breed racism. Totally 100% behind the writer, Benjamin Wong and OA Musa.


I came from a government public school, and I have to say that it really isn't any better there. Each race still mixes mostly amongst themselves. The really odd thing is that the groups of friends who are truly multicultural tend to be those who are more liberal-minded and speak English for preference. The conservative types tend to stick amongst themselves, and are not likely to mingle unless they change their mindset. (Yeah, they're the types who grow up to join UMNO later on...)

Also, I would like to point out that the public school that I attended was located in an area with no small Malay population (Kelana Jaya) yet they were very few Malays attending the school. I only had TWO Malay classmates in a class of 40 . Now why is that? Where did they go to? You think maybe they have their own schools which is exclusive to Malays only? I wouldn't know. Just speculating, but at least vernacular schools will accept ANY students regardless of their race.

And how do you think the non-Malays feel when we finally realize that no matter how hard we study, getting a scholarship as well as a place in a local university is like striking lottery. Non-Malays whose parents aren't affluent enough to afford a private education are screwed. Meanwhile, our Malay classmates are assured a place even if they did worse in their exams. Its our very first taste of 'Ketuanan Melayu' right there, and believe me...it breeds no small amount of resentment.

Mukhriz has no idea what he's talking about. You want national unity? It will take more than just putting the kids all together in the same schools. Sooner or later, the poisonous political atmosphere in this country will take hold of their minds, whether we like it or not. That is the actual problem that we need to address.

written by OverseasMsian, December 05, 2008 15:48:36
My goodness. If we can't even agree our kids to be in te same scool, ow can we be in same country? Sorry te letter after g on my keyboard doesn't work.


I think the point being made here is putting the students in the same school is the least of the problems. Address the bigger issue first.

Adults play no small role in shaping the mind of their kids, and there really is no use in letting the kids mingle if their families resent each other due to racial differences.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 8
...
written by techgeek, December 05, 2008 16:09:24
What's the point of putting all our children in the same school, going through the same system? The moment they want to choose their careers, their race comes into play. It doesn't matter how good you are at Bahasa Malaysia, English, Chinese or Tamil! It doesn't matter how much they understand each other or how 'united' they are! I studied in a Malay school where only 3 out of 40 students were Chinese. My BM grades are better than most Malays! And for crying out loud, I was the first Chinese head prefect! What does it ALL matter? My future is still limited and restricted because I'm not MALAY! It's not whether we integrate our children into the same school system. Don't you guys get it??? As long as there is racial discrimination (in universities, job opportunities, etc.), there will always be race-related problems!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 10
...
written by ToeJam, December 05, 2008 16:19:24

written by bogeyman, December 05, 2008 12:16:58

You commentors are only here to bash UMNO for anything that they do....

Toejam, you're so sick with hatred that only your opinion holds.... really sad.


Hmmm... I wonder what I have written that gave me away that I am sick with hatred and only my opinion mattered.

Just like everyone here, I happened to have an opinion of this matter and I shared it - just like you. I supposed one can observe you have an opinion of me and it does seem, to you, only your opinion mattered.... hence, one can conclude that we have the same hatred but we just hold differing views, wouldn't you agree? Or are you under the illusion that only your opinion is the RIGHT one?

I think you have may provided a wonderful example of pot calling the kettle....

fyi only, I don't bash UMNO for ANYTHING. Just one example to highlight my position will suffice; I am very supportive of their decision to sack Zaid. Now he is free to move on.

------

Dear AO Musa,
if what you shared of your life is true, then I take my hat off to you because you are a determined person. Sorry to say I didn't get those supports that you mentioned either.

Maybe I lack the mental capacity to explain my position clearly so let me try again; I can appreciate why some communities are against one-race school. BUT I AM NOT AGAINST NO-RACE (OR ALL-RACE) SCHOOLS.... that means "english" is the main language and all students can offer their native language as another language.

Take care, brother.... and sorry if my words have caused hurt to you

report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by Malaysiaputra, December 05, 2008 16:22:26
written by techgeek, December 05, 2008 16:09:24

What's the point of putting all our children in the same school,

=====

You are right. Let us not let Mukhriz and his like use the issue of language as an excuse to destroy the vernacular school and thus our values.

Even without the vernacular schools, the hijacked NEP policies will still be practiced.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by Rhan, December 05, 2008 17:02:33
get rid of vernacular schools, they breed racism


bodohman, prove it!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 6
...
written by renoir, December 05, 2008 17:34:45
I wonder why the administrator(s) would allow anyone to deface this page by allowing the writer's alleged name to occupy about half of it.

It's a waste of time to reply to this garbage, so I'll try to be brief:

>By putting together the future generation of Malaysia under one school roof, we are taking the first step in national unity: allowing them to socialise and experience racial diversity when young.]]

The French, Russian, American, and Chinese - all countries with terrible civil wars - were largely homogeneous societies where people had gone to the same schools and socialized among themselves, besides sharing a basically similar culture. A cursory knowledge of, for example, the American Civil War, would be sufficient to realize that this was a war which often saw friends fighting against friends, and even brothers against brothers. General Grant reportedly told an old friend - someone who allegedly had lent him money before the Civil War - that he would accept no terms of defeat other than "unconditional surrender."

The first step towards unity is to dissolve racist political parties, racist rhetoric and actions, racist laws, all of which UMNO and BN had been largely responsible.

>I have been through two education systems, the first being a reputable private school, dominated by Chinese, and the second was a standard government primary school. Now on hindsight, I can proudly say that the greatest educational experience in my life came from the government school where I was exposed to different cultures and religions.]]

One shouldn't be shy about naming that "reputable private school" - unless it's not reputable - or even the years of study there. About being "proud," I guess the Indian girl who was mercilessly insulted by racist remarks from her history teacher might have a different opinion. So indeed would thousands of other Malaysians with similar experiences. Anyone who glibly talks about being "exposed to different cultures and religions" should tell us a bit about those cultures and religions. Want an in-depth public debate with someone like me - a fella who know little about such things? Just name time and place.

> It took much difficulty and time for me to adapt to the new environment of diverse mix of cultures, but it was all worth it as it taught me the important lessons of tolerance and understanding, of how different people think differently and to be more open minded and accept different opinions.]]

Many of our current UMNO ministers are either from national schools or international schools where there were supposedly a "mix of cultures." We've seen how some of them have waved the keris, threatened to burn down the Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall, put journalists under ISA for their protection, and unloaded molotov cocktails in an MP's residence - all in a spirit of "tolerance and understanding."

>Based on my experience, I find those who have studied in vernacular schools to be the least tolerant.]]

Obviously your experience isn't worth much. Unless you're Einstein or the Buddha, you won't find much takers on arguments based on your one shallow experience. Now, I was a former high school teacher from the 60s to the end of the 70s, before I started writing columns or college teaching, and I can say that those from vernacular schools have generally been most tolerant, most civilized, not to mention most hard working. The only group that could match those students were from another system which comprised mostly of one race - the Malay boys from those all-Malay boarding schools that have aroused no concern by UMNO about their monoethnic, monoreligious culture. These Malay boys were highly intelligent and mingled easily with non-Malay folks in the town, and they were very close to most non-Malay teachers like myself. Why? Because it was not so much the school system as the extant general worldview, formed by an essentially non-racist government, that engendered the harmony. Malaysia under Tunku Abdul Rahman was a pretty tolerant nation and that tolerance and racial harmony could be seen in public as well as private lives.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 3
...
written by Goodbites, December 05, 2008 18:38:35
I do not see how integration of school system will improve racial harmony when our politicians are not practicing racial harmony.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 2
...
written by Desert Fox, December 05, 2008 19:22:55
In M'sia, private schools are a result of those in BN obtaining a licence to operate a money making institution and to divide those who can afford from those who can't afford and government schools basically are for those who can't afford but if you want discipline then go to chinese schools,otherwise the others will suffice smilies/tongue.gif
The problem is not so much the medium of instruction but more the fact that there is no discipline,integrity in our education system. Just take a look at the text books.... they suck. They always portray Ali with a songkok,Lee Lan in a sam foo and Leela with a putu. Ask any student in a kebangsaan school how often they get off from lessons because the teachers are having a meeting or khursus. Shame,shame,shame.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by Steven Tan, December 05, 2008 19:56:30
I support the "One School System" for Integrity and Nation Unity. It's not that easy to convince people BUT it can be done if my suggestion become reality. This concept is not only good for the country but for the students as well. So, I hope our government will seriously consider this suggestion as soon as possible.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 1
...
written by educationist, December 05, 2008 20:19:00
I have *****ed on this link thinking it will espoused some intellectual discourse which may be of interest.
But as many bloggers have commented there's nothing in it that merits serious discussion.
The bottom line is this: if at the end of their education, these one school system pupils are faced with the same qouta to enter courses of their choice at varsity, will they feel any more assimilated? the list can go on.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 7
...
written by Goodbites, December 05, 2008 20:49:20
Vernacular schools have served the non-bumis well as we can see from the economic point of view. It does not have any effect on racial harmony as we can live together peacefully. The real danger to racial harmony is UMNO who continue to stir up racial issues to get support. Do not be deceived. Their proposal may appear to be reasonable and noble on the surface. Once they have the upper hand, they will hijack it for their own interest. Look what happened to NEP as a good example. Instead of 30%, some are now asking for 70%. Beware!!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 5
...
written by Darth Vader, December 05, 2008 21:21:20
I have said it in my other posting and i will say it again here.

gomen change BAHASA MALAYSIA to BAHASA MELAYU. This is wrong. If you talk about integration, then name it BAHASA MALAYSIA. Even in Indonesia, the called it BAHASA INDONESIA and NOT, I repeat NOT BAHASA MELAYU. if you dispute this and say indonesian not MELAYU, then look at yr ancestor. some of the malays have roots in indonesia. Dare you call indonesian not MALAY.

In all government forms, REMOVE the WORD called "BANGSA". Gomen so stupid to differentiate race just by looking at the names? Tan Ah Kow is Chinese or Indian or Malay or under lain lain category? Same goes for Ali Bin Bakar and also Muthu A/L Muniandy. So who inculcate racism?

Why some Malays and Indian enrol their kids in Chinese school? They saw something which others dont see. Answer is very simple. Economics and marketability of their kids. i e. future of their kids. Prime minister of Australia can speak Mandarin. Why?

I am a MALAYSIAN (UMNO goons will call me kaum pendatang especially tht monkey from Bukit bendera). I am PROUD of BAHASA MALAYSIA.


written by bogeyman, December 05, 2008 12:16:58

You commentors are only here to bash UMNO for anything that they do.... we are not talking about UmNO's racist policies here.... we are now talking about education system towards integration


Dear Bogeyman,
Just questions for you to ponder.
1.Education Minister is from which political party? UMNO, MCA, MIC?
2.PM is selected from which political party? UMNO, MCA, MIC?
3.Who set the direction of our education system? PM? Then refer to question # 2
4.Why is it that in SPM, when you score 8A1 in all subjuects and you get F9 in BM, you get grade 2 and cant qualify to go to local uni? Do you mean that these brilliant students who did so well in other subjects are idits?
5. Why there is Matriculation program reserved for you know who?


report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by adamckteh, December 05, 2008 21:24:22
Any vernacular schools churned out extremists, unpatriotic citizens, and traitors of the nation? What is wrong with the vernacular schools? The culprits are the policies of the BN government.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 5
..., Lowly rated comment [Show]
...
written by cheekhiaw, December 06, 2008 00:12:20
May be those people do not want to have anything to do, least of all unite, with idiots like you...

xxx
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by JaguhKampung, December 06, 2008 00:26:23
I will support that all goes to national school if;

1. Government abolish all vernacular schools including sekolah agama
2. Government abolish racial quotas to all universities including MARA etc
3. Government abolish racial quotas for higher education loans
4. Government abolish racial quotas for all positions of University Chancellors, lecturere, headmasters and teachers in all schools, universities including UM, UKM etc
5. Everything is based on merit.
6. Everyone study and learn Bahasa Malaysia, NOT Bahasa Melayu.

Datuk Mukhriz, if you agree to this, you got my vote to have one unificatin system.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Loi Bih Siang Benjamin, December 06, 2008 00:33:56
benjamin, i am sorry that i have to insult your intelligence, is that what your teachers taught you how to "reason"?!
firstly, when we talk about national unity we must find the reason why we have national "disunity" in the first place.
a). U think if we study together (under one roof since young), then we will achieve national unity and have a harmonious society? let me tell you something: BN component parties are functioning "under one roof" for the purpose of achiving national unity, why the umno goons still call gerakan and mca pengdatang??
b). i have malay friends who got 3rd class SPM/STPM result to enter local university and dropout subsequently, do you think i am supportive of the existing system and pretend that we have national unity??
c). It is your personal experience in sekolah kebangsaan, but how many non-bumi students in sekolah kebangsaan have you talked to?
d). vernacular schools reflect multiracialism of our country, it is the strength of our country.
e). go and do your research on the root cause of the national "disunity" first.
f) can u guarantee that if we only have 1-school system, we won't be called "pengdatang"? we won't be disciminated against in university enrolment and admission into public sector? we won't be denied the opportunity to tender for government projects? we won't be denied to apply for government SME loans??? if you can't, pls keep your mouth shut!!!!
I am sorry to tell u that: you're stupid, very!

i am going to change my name!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 8
...
written by renoir, December 06, 2008 01:26:27
I distinctly remember that I'd posted the second part of my article, so I don't know why it disappeared. I would like RPK to tell me what's going on, if he has the time. Needless to say, I'd been very supportive of him because of his belief in free speech, I would like to know who has been practising unwarranted censorship in his blog.

The second part is most important because of this assertion:

>The education system’s one and only purpose is to impart knowledge and skills to our future generation to prepare them to be useful members of society. The imparting of culture and "mother tongue" should never be the sole responsibility of the system]]

As I implied in my posting, this is totally untrue. Modern education began with the establishment of what was called "mechanic institutes" in England during the early part of the 19th century, and though skills were a part of the curricula an important emphasis was cultural values that the ruling class deemed important for the unwashed masses. The lower classes were to be inculcated not only with work ethic, but also with what Matthew Arnold called "the best culture of their nation." This was the culture of the nobility, which the middle-class was to absorb and then pass on to the lower class. The lower classes soon smelled a rat, and many left the institutes to read up newspapers and magazines in the institutes' reading rooms. As I mentioned in the missing posting, this lower class habit gave birth to the modern public library.

In short, right from the beginning, education had been seen as a cultural vehicle. And of course, the mother tongue is very much a part of any cultural education.

LChuah
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 2

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
 
The Silent Roar
 BUY THE BOOK HERE
 **STOCKS NOW AVAILABLE**
 
** SPONSORED LINKS **
Will NATO become a global army? More..
Some Images Hosted With
Thank You ImageShack!
 BLOGGERS AGAINST ISA
People's Declaration

Powered and Optimized for:
Malaysia Today by MT-TEAM