A+ | A- | Reset
Home arrow The Blogs arrow Special Reports arrow Kuala Terengganu is up in the air for now

Kuala Terengganu is up in the air for now PDF Print
Posted by admin   
Friday, 05 December 2008 11:08

The Kuala Terengganu parliamentary by-election will show whether Barisan Nasional has gained ground among Malays or if Pakatan Rakyat can overcome the disarray among its members, writes ZUBAIDAH ABU BAKAR

THERE is one word that Parti Islam SeMalaysia does not want bandied about during the impending Kuala Terengganu by-election: sodomy.

Pas leaders worry that discussing such a sensitive issue in the conservative Malay community can be detrimental to their party's chances of wresting the parliamentary seat from Barisan Nasional, as conservative Malays are often susceptible to being influenced by such allegations.

Unless Umno has not learned its lesson in losing the Permatang Pauh by-election last August, campaigning for Kuala Terengganu is unlikely to be clouded by the sodomy allegations against Parti Keadilan Rakyat de facto leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, now pending in court.

Post-Permatang Pauh analysis found that the screening of the video clip of Anwar's young accuser, his former aide Saiful Bukhari Azlan, swearing on the Quran had backfired. Voters were put off and gave Anwar a thumping victory over Barisan Nasional's Datuk Arif Shah Omar Shah.

But politicians often throw caution to the wind. They would take the risk if they thought harping on the sodomy issue would bring down their opponent.

Many may not be aware that Terengganu Pas once banned the former deputy prime minister from speaking about the sodomy allegations against him. When Anwar went on a nationwide tour to counter the allegations, the state Pas liaison committee reached a consensus not to allow him to include Terengganu in his itinerary.

But PKR and Pas insiders say there was more to the matter.

The real reason, they say, was that the more conservative quarters in Pas, headed by party president Datuk Seri Abdul Hadi Awang and including Terengganu chief Datuk Mus-taffa Ali, were not at ease with the full backing given to Anwar by the some of the more progressive and younger leaders in the party.

It was also perceived that the Terengganu faction, then keen to cooperate with Umno, was attempting to distance itself from Anwar, leading to the hush-hush Pas-Umno unity talks after the March 8 polls.

Anwar reportedly took the unwelcome gesture in his stride, continuing his tour around the country to tell his side of the story on the sodomy allegations.

Ironically, he shared the stage with Pas leaders elsewhere during that tour: with Hadi at a ceramah in Kedah, with Pas spiritual leader Datuk Nik Abdul Aziz Nik Mat in Kelantan and with Perak Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin in Perak.

But he was not welcome in Hadi's home state of Terengganu.

However, PKR did address the issue in Terengganu. Batu Buruk assemblyman Syed Azman Syed Ahmad Nawawi, seen as part of the pro-Anwar group in Pas, organised a small ceramah in KT to explain the sodomy issue.

Anwar himself lay low; PKR strategist and Machang assemblyman Saifuddin Nasution Ismail took the microphone instead. Other than Syed Azman, no state Pas leader was on that stage.

However, Anwar's trip to Marang on Oct 22 to speak at a ceramah at Hadi's famed Rusila Mosque near Kuala Terengganu showed a Terengganu Pas "more open" to accepting Anwar as leader of Pakatan Rakyat.

Pas-linked blog Siasahdaily posted pictures of Anwar and Mustaffa seated side by side inside the mosque.

But whether Pas hardliners will accept Pakatan's machinery, at least for the by-election, remains to be seen.

Malay voters, who make up more than 88 per cent of Kuala Terengganu's electorate, are again in focus.

With the debate on ketuanan Melayu, the by-election may indicate if Umno's allegation that Pakatan Rakyat is "selling out Malays" has gained ground against the coalition governing Kedah, Penang, Perak, Selangor and Kelantan.

Umno members have criticised Anwar's stance on the New Economic Policy and are debating the social contract relating to Malay rights, Malay rulers, Islam as the country's official religion and Bahasa Malaysia as the national language.

Saifuddin said: "It will show how effective Umno has been in regaining ground since its leaders have been telling Malays that Anwar and his allies cannot be trusted to take care of their well-being.

"Pakatan Rakyat leaders, too, have to deal with the disarray in the opposition coalition over Malay-Muslim issues."

Pas is not optimistic of commanding the Malay vote either. Its leaders are under pressure from the grassroots over issues such as the sale of alcohol in Selangor, multilingual road signs in Penang and pig farms in Selangor and Kedah, besides Malay sovereign rights, all of which may dilute Malay support of the opposition.

A clear acknowledgement that Pakatan Rakyat has not fully secured the Malay ground was a joint agreement signed by Anwar, Hadi and DAP supremo Lim Kit Siang that Pakatan remained committed to upholding the Constitution's provisions on the rights of Malays.

There may spoilers: Ang-katan Keadilan Insan Malaysia president Hanafi Mamat and 89-year-old grandmother Maimun Yusuf are keen to contest, but the real contest is between Pas and Umno.

In the March general election, the late Datuk Razali Ismail managed a 628-majority win in a three-cornered fight with Pas vice-president Mohamad Sabu and Maimun.

Political watchers are hedging their bets for now, calling odds even at 50:50 for Umno and Pas. (NST)

Comments (8)Add Comment
...
written by gundohing, December 05, 2008 11:26:58
Zubaidah, you talked about if Pakatan Rakyat can overcome the percieved disarray among its members, why are you silent about the disarray in UMNO?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 27
...
written by Oscar Winner, December 05, 2008 11:27:38
For latest news before by-election day,
Please follow closely Malaysia Today.
To win, UMNO will abuse power all the way,
One wonders to what god they daily pray,
Ignorant KT folks may buy everything BN say,
Let us wake them up before it’s too late......
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 16
...
written by hiro, December 05, 2008 11:29:22
I expected nothing less from NST. Sodomy II is a demonstration of the administration of criminal justice and criminal law enforcement going wrong in this country. Why wouldn't PAS want to highlight the failure of BN government to rule fairly? The article is mischievous to say the least by assuming that the sodomy allegation is so true that PAS is afraid to use it.

Whatever the spin is, it's time for KT folks to wake up. This government continues to offend everyone's sense of fairplay and justice. There is still NO OPEN TENDER despite pronouncements to the contrary after March 8. It means contracts still go to UMNOputras, not the ordinary Malay folks. There is still no declaration of assets despite much pronouncements after March 8.

PM may be pushing for MCAC and JAC, but the devil is in the details - so no one should hold their breath for some miraculous breakthrough until we see everything that we need to see.

For instance, for the MCAC - who are the eminent persons sitting on the advisory board - what criteria is used for their appointment in the first place - I mean, if Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye sits there would that command confidence of the public? How will the oversight committee be formed - are there deadlines, teeth, consequences for non-compliance?

The special complaints commission is also a non-started when what we need is a police ombudsman in the form of IPCMC to whack the head of IGP who tells us that we're save on the streets - misrepresenting to 24 million Malaysians as to the true state of our criminal statistics. It's a crying shame that the cabinet and the National Economic Council have decided to adopt his view and wish away the problem that's happening to someone every one knows at some point in time - snatch theft, break ins, shoulder dislocation due to a fall after being pushed by bandits etc..

And reforming elections? Silent - absolute silence - just because the opposition won big does not mean the system is ok. If the system is ok, the opposition might have just won the elections.

How does this compare with the "disarray" in the opposition rank? What disarray? A few harsh exchanges? We're seeing even more in the BN camp. That's nothing compared with FAILED governance.

And Terengganu government buying Mercs because Perdana service is expensive - that's absolutely laughable.

The way I see it, there's so much more ammunition to bury UMNO in KT than they can pick the "problems" of the opposition. The opposition is just about to have shadow committees at federal level. Selangor and Penang is doing just fine, and Kedah has just backed down from doing something silly with regards to housing quota. I say they are not doing too badly - the most important thing is they are clean. The same can't be said for BN government - mired not only in scandals, but haphazard policies that are making us laughing stock of the world.

As long as PAS seals its lips on Islamic Nation, and adopt a more inclusive approach, it'll do just fine.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 13
...
written by lonewolf, December 05, 2008 12:15:11
Zubaidah is hired by UMNO to find the problem of Pakatan Rakyat and blow it out of proportion. Why highlight the bad things about Pakatan rakyat and none about UMNO? Because you are being well serviced by Umno goons.
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 10
...
written by Frankfurtguy, December 05, 2008 12:36:19
Young Malaysians with family members in KT
please "educate" / "inform" your family in KT:

tell them to teach BN a lesson
tell them to vote anybody as long as it is not BN
tell them BN is going to make their live even more miserable in the next 2-4 years
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 13
...
written by ahmadneil, December 05, 2008 13:13:52
Sent umno to hell,for that is where they belong.Yes,we can!Change is coming!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 6
...
written by Proarte, December 05, 2008 20:32:37

This election is not about the merits of 'local democracy' over a 'parachute' candidate. It is about a turf war in PAS of the 'progressives' over the 'Hadi' faction and the future of the Pakatan alliance. The idea that a local 'Pak Kadok' is preferable to a charismatic PAS leader of huge popularity on the ground such as Mat Sabu is plainly ridiculous.

UMNO would love to have an opposition 'Pak Kadok' in parliament. Mat Sabu instead will give make them decidedly uneasy. Let us remind ourselves if we did not have 'parachute' candidates, we would not have DAP as the state government in Penang or Kit Siang as MP for Ipoh Timur.

When we have the 'conservative' wing in PAS showing their Taliban tendencies and their turncoat behaviour towards 'Pakatan' by willing to do deals with UMNO, it would be stupid to support their candidate. If Mat Sabu is not selected it would mean a victory for the 'ulamak' wing and this will mean the impossibility of a viable Pakatan.

PAS at the best of times is a stumbling block to a viable coalition because of its Islamic State ambitions and atavistic world view. It is fair to say that DAP and PAS have disparate ideologies. There is also distrust of PAS within the DAP and PKR ranks over their commitment to the democratic process and 'Ketuanan Rakyat'. Hadi did openly say that PAS would not support Pakatan if Muslims were not 'dominant' in the coalition. DAP and PKR have openly rejected racism and religious bigotry and made that a central platform of their political convictions.

There are honest and sincere politicians in PAS and they are mostly aligned to the 'progressive' wing of PAS and include Mat Sabu, Husam Musa , Dr Dzulkifli Ahmad etc. If there is any chance of Pakatan being viable then we have to witness the ascendency of this camp in PAS.

Mat Sabu may not be a 'local' but he is a high profile PAS figure. He may be only an ITM graduate with a folksy and simpleton manner, but he is an intellectual with great humanity. He is deeply religious but a self confessed 'liberal'. He oratorical skills are legendary and he is widely popular on the ground.

Remember even a 'giant' local like Hadi Awang was booted out ignominiousy in the 2004 parliamentary elections. Sabu only lost by a whisker in 2008. His broad appeal and close friendship which he has with Guan Eng and Karpal of DAP will be helpful in getting Chinese support who are the King makers in this election.

Do not expect DAP to lend their support to PAS in this election if Mat Sabu is rejected. It will portend the direction in which PAS is heading and ultimately affect the viability of this loose coalition known as 'Pakatan'.

There is more to it than meets the eye in this election
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 5
...
written by Bigjoe99, December 06, 2008 09:14:31
This is insane. PR strategy in this election must be to put PAS up front as an equal partner. The problem is PAS itself is divided into faction. That is the real issue. BN strategy would be to play up Anwar and make PAS look like it plays second fiddle. The Erdogan faction must go out and win the heart and minds of a conservative base without alienating the Terengganu faction...
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
 
Some Images Hosted With
Thank You ImageShack!
 BLOGGERS AGAINST ISA

Powered and Optimized for:
Malaysia Today by MT-TEAM