A+ | A- | Reset
Home

In US elections, some parallels with Malaysia PDF Print
Posted by admin   
Thursday, 06 November 2008 23:01
By Brian Yap

NOV 6 - Four years after the world ridiculed the United States for re-electing George W Bush, the most powerful nation on earth more than redeemed itself by decisively putting an articulate, intellectually curious and inspiring president in the White House.

Brian Yap is a journalist who writes from the place where politics, the arts and technology meet.

After decades of steering America dangerously to the right, the Republican party suffered a rejection that will leave it in the wilderness for the foreseeable future.

Finally, the dominance of conservatism has come to a screeching halt, leaving the Republican party, the party of the Christian right, trickle-down economics and hawkish foreign policy in disarray.

It was, in a sense, the American version of our 8 March political tsunami.

So of course, there are parallels that can be drawn, and lessons we can learn.

Like Umno and the Barisan Nasional, the Republican party of today has become a party that thrives on fear and division. It was red state versus blue state, small town versus big cities.

Barack Obama is not a patriotic American, they argued. He has Hussein for a middle name, and is a closet Muslim.

He's an elitist.

Or a socialist.

If Obama was Malaysian, he'd probably be accused by Umno of being a traitor to his race, an agent of the Jews and an American puppet.

And it would probably still work.

But the Illinois senator's triumph shows that when people become more educated and informed, they become less susceptible to fear, and more secure about their economic and political situation, as well as their cultural and religious beliefs.

That is why I believe politicians whose platform consists of racial supremacy depend on keeping Malaysians ignorant. Maybe that also explains the state of our education system.

But Umno needs to realise that if it continues to pander to the extreme elements of society, it too will one day become like the Republicans today, a party on the fringe. It's a lesson it should have learnt after 8 March, but clearly didn't.

The resounding Democratic victory also offers lessons for Pakatan Rakyat parties: Don't accept conventional wisdom as gospel. The American electoral map has largely been static for the past few decades-some states are solidly Republican, others Democrat.

The ones that can go either way, swing states, then become the focus of both candidates.

But something interesting happened with the Obama campaign. He decided to challenge the status quo, spending time and money on solid Republican states, matching his rhetoric that there is no blue or red America.

It paid off, and the US electoral map, which has its roots in the Civil War, has finally been redrawn. Obama even managed to win Virginia, the former capital of the pro-slavery Confederacy, which has never voted for a Democratic president since 1964.

Imagine DAP winning in Terengganu, and you get an idea of how implausible that victory was.

Part of Obama's success, I believe, comes from the courage of his convictions. For too long, the Republicans have portrayed the US as a centre-right nation, leaving the left-leaning Democrats always on the defensive about its beliefs.

Unsurprisingly, the party was viewed by many of its own supporters as spineless. Plus, backtracking doesn't inspire confidence in those you're trying to win over either.

But Obama dared to voice his opposition to the Iraq war when it was considered anti-American to do so. When the war became unpopular, his dissent became proof of his good judgement instead.

Pakatan should bear this in mind when facing its political enemies. If Tan Sri Khalid Ibrahim feels that appointing Low Siew Moi is the right thing to do, he should unapologetically make the case to the Malay community.

The softening of his position simply gives credence to his opponents' call for racism to triumph common sense.

At the same time, it weakens the support from those who want an end to the cancer that is racial politics.

If Pakatan truly wants to make Malaysia a more inclusive, progressive nation, it needs to courageously convince the Malay community that it only stands to benefit.

Zaid Ibrahim's recent speech on ketuanan Melayu was so powerful because he refused to mince words on what he believes is true.

Of course, not all Malaysians will accept transformation. But the world is changing, and Malaysia is no exception.

The US elections marked a generational shift, as a new generation of voters joined the electorate, many of them inspired by Obama's candidacy. His campaign made registering new voters a priority, and appealed to the young by talking about relevant issues like jobs, technology and global warming.

The campaign also used 21st century tools like the Internet and mobile phones to not only disseminate information, but also to mobilise, organise and raise funds.

These are all ideas that Pakatan parties can emulate. Older Malaysians are stuck in their ways, but the younger generation is less weighed down by the baggage of history.

And young Malaysians, if there's anything to learn from the Obama victory, it is that you can make history, that the future isn't destined to be a repeat of the past.

Unsurprisingly, the Obama victory has made minorities in Malaysia wonder if a non-Malay can ever become Prime Minister.

This, I believe, is a silly question to ask.

Instead, we should be wondering if we have produced a leader who can connect with the majority Malay Muslim population and win enough support from the community.

Someone who inspires all young Malaysians to get involved. Someone who appeals to our hopes and dreams not our fears.

Someone who breaks the racial barrier while making race a non-issue.

Because that's what Barack Obama did. Until we produce a leader like that, I think the question is moot.

Comments (7)Add Comment
...
written by Darth Vader, November 07, 2008 01:34:38
Unsurprisingly, the Obama victory has made minorities in Malaysia wonder if a non-Malay can ever become Prime Minister.


The UMNOPutras will definately fan racial sentiments to ensure that this does not happen. They will ISAed the person who dares to claim this on the grounds that he or she incite racial disharmony. Just look at what YB Theresa Kok has to go thru when she was accused of by MSM and also the pendatang from indonesia called Toyol..... opps.. Toyo. YB was ISAed and threaten with Molotov Cocktail and death threats by the lap dogs of the UMNOPutras. Our beloved PDRM. Said to investigate but until now no arrest has been made and keeping quiet about it.

Frankly i would like to see Malaysia be govern by capable leaders regardless of race, skin colour and creed.

Oh.. ya... our PM MUST BE ELECTED BY THE MASS POPULATION!! Not in the hands of a few people.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 13
...
written by cheekymate, November 07, 2008 06:29:56
I do agree to some degree that there are parallels between the US elections and Malaysia. The Democrats are likened to the Pakatan of our country and the young generation constitute towards an evolution of a new era of brave, vocal population ever ready for reforms. True democracy is enjoyed in the US but sadly, this is where the similarity ends as illustrated by our lopsided media and the wielding of the draconian laws on the oppressed.
However, through good strategies, we can still overcome these deficits. The internet and efficient dissemination of information as rightfully raised by the writer are indeed powerful tools which can work to our advantage. Strong ambassadors in our fight for justice will be a definite asset towards this end (like Oprah Winfrey, Michael Jordan, Muhammad Ali for Obama). Our heros in RPK, Zaid Ibrahim and the likes of them are few and in between. We need many more of these selfless fighters to champion our cause and instil the values of truth, righteousness and justice in all of us. Only with a well thought out stategised pathway towards our fights, will we then enjoy the fruits of our battles. And only then, will there arise a true leader who will bring Malaysia once more to the shores of glory.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 5
...
written by liberal, November 07, 2008 08:54:08
In echoing the famous cry from Martin L King Jr. “I have a dream…...”, finally, that near impossible dream befallen in USA on 4th Nov 2008. The American had proven to the world that civil rights are indeed flourished in the land of dreams where they proudly call home.
The Malaysian started the wind of change on 8 Mar 2008 but just missed a fraction for a historic victory. With such an unpopular BN government trying its best to hold on to that slim majority, I for one am pretty sure that dream of historic victory will be realized in the foreseeable future.
However, with racial remarks that came from PKR in particular PAS, I have doubt that the Malaysian dream will ever be realized in a few generation to come.
We are simply short of someone who dare challenge the norm and make us all proud to be Malaysian. Our closest challenger Sir RPK was unfortunately ISAed and his revolutionized forward thinking will undoubtedly realize our Malaysian Dream.
“I too have a dream……..” dream dream dream.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by scottiebabie, November 07, 2008 10:33:13
although i do agree with alot of what's written, i wouldnt quite write the Republican Party off quite as yet. history has taught us that even the most popular incumbent parties gets voted out of office either through the arrogance & complacency of incumbency or more likely, just voter fickleness.

even though personally i dislike Mahathir, i do agree with his dual poignant statements of "its easier to say change than to actually change" & "Bush has contributed much towards the acceptance of Obama". also dont forget that Obama won the vast majority of the electoral votes, John McCain won 46.4% of the popular vote.

most newly elected leader enjoy of high public acceptance & opinion initially (ala Pak Lah) & while its good to be optimistic & hopeful, its in the deeds that would Obama's presidency (again ala Pak Lah's much derided legacy of promises unfulfilled)
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by asguard, November 07, 2008 11:07:45
Here Martin Luther King ...words and dreams is impoosible to take root here because of UMNO .....
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by educationist, November 07, 2008 11:24:20
The parallels, are there but we are probably at least 221 years behind.
But, yes it's an inspirational win and it brings hope that a true Malaysian will arise in the future to lead our nation.
Perhaps, it may not happen in our lifetimes -those of the immediate post independence era but if the steps initiated by PR takes root, it may not be yoo far off.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by cheekhiaw, November 07, 2008 11:42:13
PARALLEL BUT OPPOSITE

The 2 countries may be in parallel but they are going in opposite directions!

xxx
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
 
The Silent Roar
 BUY THE BOOK HERE
 **STOCKS NOW AVAILABLE**
 
** SPONSORED LINKS **
Will NATO become a global army? More..
Some Images Hosted With
Thank You ImageShack!
 BLOGGERS AGAINST ISA
People's Declaration

Powered and Optimized for:
Malaysia Today by MT-TEAM