A+ | A- | Reset
Home arrow Guest Columnists arrow The Mundane Face of the Global Caliphate

The Mundane Face of the Global Caliphate PDF Print
Posted by admin   
Saturday, 09 August 2008 11:09

There are, presently, a plethora of Islamist organisations and mass movements who have taken the notion of the global Caliphate as their goal.

Farish A. Noor

Today there is much talk, accompanied by some degree of unnecessary speculation and fear-mongering, about the claims and ambitions of Islamists who seek to create a global Caliphate as the panacea for the ills of Muslim society worldwide. That such talk of a pan-Islamic global project would spook the spooks of the international anti-terror industry is, of course, not entirely surprising for nothing seems to agitate the public more these days than the idea of a couple of Muslims getting together and plotting the imminent take-over of the universe.

There are, presently, a plethora of Islamist organisations and mass movements who have taken the notion of the global Caliphate as their goal. Groups like the Hizb'ut Tahrir openly proclaim their vision of a pan-Islamic world; while mainstream Islamist parties ranging from the Ikhwan'ul Muslimin of Egypt and the Arab world to the Jama'at-e Islami of South Asia to the Pan-Malaysian Islamic party of Malaysia have also spread their networks and contacts beyond the host countries where they first emerged. International conferences bring together Islamists from all corners of the globe with the frequency we associate more with international governmental or business conferences; and the internet has already created a virtual Islamoscape where Islamists from every country on the planet may interact simultaneously in real time. In many respects, such a global pan-Islamic universe already exists, and it can be said that the pan-Islamic world is a virtual empire where the sun never sets.

Yet looking beyond the narrow concerns of securocrats obsessed with the threat of Islamic terrorism, we need to peer beneath the discursive carapace of this grand project and understand its true import and what it hopes to achieve.

In my discussions with Islamists from Pakistan to Indonesia, I have been struck by the common appeal of them all: They long to create a global pan-Islamic space where belonging to the same faith community is the only passport one needs to travel across the Muslim world unrestricted. In many respects, this is reminiscent of the travels of Ibn Battuta, the celebrated Muslim traveller whose journeys took him across Africa and all the way to Southeast Asia and beyond. Ibn Battuta was, of course a bad traveller and a fussy tourist who insisted all the time that he be served halal food and live in comfortable familiar surroundings that did not offend or contradict his Muslim sensibilities. What he sought then, and what Islamists today seek, are the same: The freedom to travel across the globe while remaining comfortable in the safe confines of a Muslim universe.

The global Islamist project can and should be seen in this light as well, for this is yet another aspect of its ambitions. Though it is sometimes couched in somewhat aggressive, if not militarist, terms of conquest and expansion, the yearning is fundamentally a mundane one.

What is it that these global Islamists seek? On one hand the project is restorative in nature: It seeks to restore to the Muslim world the cosmopolitanism and universalism that it once professed but lost with the coming of European imperialism. The Muslim world, we should remember, was global in outlook and its outreach, and Muslim merchants, scholars, diplomats and mystics travelled across the world with ease and regularity that was guaranteed by the presence of long-established networks, itineraries and a communicative infrastructure that were the sinews of this global system.

On the other hand the pan-Islamist vision is also one that is guided by the longing for safety and comfort, where itinerant Muslims feel the need to belong to a globalised world that is safe, or at least not hostile to them. In the same way that itinerant merchants and scholars of the past depended on letters of introduction and guarantees of safe passage that would allow them to travel with ease, likewise the global Islamists today seek the same assurances from an international order that ought to be protecting them. Hence the appeal to Muslim identity and a common faith and value system as the guarantee that their mobility would not be restricted.

This yearning for mobility, freedom of movement, the right to live and settle anywhere, all happen to be pragmatic, mundane and material concerns that are in fact universal and are symptoms of the globalised age we live in. The longing for an extended Islamoscape with an unbroken frontier that extents and expands continuously can and should be seen as part of the evolution of a Muslim consciousness and sensibility that is global in its scope and outlook, the pining for a global Muslim citizenship so to speak.

Already we see the first real material evidence of such a global network in the making around us: Talk of a global Muslim currency (the so-called golden Dinar) that was dismissed as pseudo-economic froth not too long ago has gained momentum and is being taken seriously by some of the more developed Muslim countries in the world. Likewise the idea of a common Muslim trading bloc, to demonstrate the combined purchasing power of the so-called 'Muslim dollar' and its market. The landscape of the Muslim world today is littered with hundreds of 'Muslim hotels' and resorts that cater to the culturally-specific needs of Muslims, whatever they might be. And there is even talk of the world's first 'Islamic car' – a project mooted by the governments of Iran and Malaysia – to help Muslims travel around the world in the comfort of a Muslim environment, albeit confined within the four doors of the passengers' cabin.

In many respects it is not surprising nor unexpected that Muslims today would have such global ambitions for we do live, after all, in a global age and where the very idea of global citizenship – underpinned by the values of cosmopolitanism and universalism – are in common currency. How does this global Islamic vision differ from that of other faith communities, who likewise wish to create a safe space for its adherents the world over; and crucially, how does this global outlook differ from the universalist claims and ambitions of global capital, that has brought us a host of safe spaces and safe networks of communication and movement from the ubiquitous Hilton hotels that are universally uniform to the phenomenon of a McWorld where the staple diet of urban denizens in many countries today happens to be Cheese Burgers with French Fries (or Freedom Fries, as they re-christened recently)?

Looking closer at some of the global Islamist networks that span the globe today, such as the Tablighi Jama'at (the world's biggest Muslim missionary movement), the network of Islamist parties with transnational or supra-national ambitions, Muslim guilds and trading groups, Sufi mystical networks and the like, we can see that they all share family resemblances with the more mainstream modes of globalisation that is capital-driven. This is not to say that Islamist networks can be likened to Mc Donalds or cast as a franchise business with branches to be opened around every street corner. But it does mean that much of the talk of pan-Islamism and the creation of global Islamist networks we have seen the world over thus far is not as alien or exotic as we might think. Fundamentally, the fundamentalists are concerned with something far more mundane and ordinary, which is to provide a service that meets a need that has become all the more prevalent in the late-Capitalist globalised age we live in: This is the sense of global citizenship and the feeling of belonging to a globalised world where one is no longer a stranger to the other. (By FARISH A. NOOR/ MySinchew)

Farish A. Noor is a Senior Fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore; and one of the founders of the www.othermalaysia.org research site.

Comments (11)Add Comment
...
written by temenggong, August 09, 2008 12:10:45
The illusions of a global caliphate is a cry of the muslims because they have nothing of their own! No car of their own, no videogames, no french fries, no nothing. Nor a blockbuster movie or a book to call their own. Not even a toothpick! Which by the way is from China, made by pork consuming chinese hands.

Whether the 1.2 billions muslims in the world exist or not means nothing to the rest of humanity. They might as well don't exist. Whereas the rest of the world continue relentlessly in global trade, development, technological pursuits and bringing affluence to their people in a socially just society.

This widespread mediocrity fuels insecurities and thus the dreams for a global caliphate.

The rest of the world have no such insecurities and see no need for any kind of bloc, other than trading blocs.

A wise muslim nation will not befriend other mediocre muslim nations from whom they have nothing to learn from, but reach out to neighbours and allies. For Malaysia that would be Asean and the US.
report abuse
disagree 8
agree 40
...
written by chin, August 09, 2008 12:44:28
China isolated itself more than once and suffered each time they did.

Muslim are isolating themselves within their minds, a global caliphate is the manifestation of these tendencies.

Instead of embracing the world as it is, they seeks to relive the glories of the past.

While the communist shut themselves within their borders, the Muslim has no such luxury so it reacts with terrorism.

Islam needs to learn to live with the rest of the world or it will destroy itself and take the rest of the world with them.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 30
...
written by Rainbowseahorse, August 09, 2008 14:17:11
Yes indeed, after having created a global Caliphate we Muslims then turned on each of our Islamic sects and blow each other to smatterings to be sent quickly to heaven….But hold on a minute here! WE ARE ALREADY blowing up & killing our own Muslims brothers, sisters, mothers, children, babies each day all in the name of which particular sect we are from. Nice and peaceful world this “Global Caliphate” concept, but no thanks!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 22
...
written by FFT, August 09, 2008 15:07:28
How's this as the face of the global caliphate?

report abuse
disagree 4
agree 28
...
written by mrbean, August 09, 2008 16:46:15
The Americans and the west won't let this happen... hahahahaha...
It is already synonymous with terrorism , it has been hijacked... go on dreaming...
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 8
..., Lowly rated comment [Show]
...
written by Limang, August 09, 2008 21:27:26
You Muslims can't even solve your own problems, rule your own country properly with justice and freedom, treat your own people with respect and affection, and you want to crete a world community and conquer the world!

Look at how UMNO rules Malaysia as an example of a disastrous Muslim governance and you will get what I mean. It is bringing the country to disaster and ruin and destroying the Malay race by making them insecure, bigoted, narrow-minded, backward, subsidy-dependent, weak and out to soak the blood of other races with their thuggish behaviour as a conduit of their weakness - and you think you can rule the world!

Tell me one Muslim country that is a model of peace, progress, open-mindedness, justice, trustworthiness, progressive, enlightenment and I will show you how to build a ladder to the moon.

There is a BIG DIFFERENCE BETWEEN DREAMING AND REALITY. But dream on and keep dreaming - at least you won't do any harm to other peace-loving non-Muslims.
report abuse
disagree 6
agree 14
...
written by 1st2stay, August 09, 2008 22:29:36
Hi, Farish Noor, and thanks for another enlightening article!
It is so sad, that the comments above are more 'muslim-bashing' than actually picking up on what was articulated. smilies/sad.gif
Of course, we all have a sense of belonging, want to encounter familiar environs wherever we travel, know and be sure of the suitable food and drinks. I have to agree, what we find is a standardised 'Western Culture', from Hilton to McD. I personally would very much appreciate a global Muslim culture, halal food, hotels, travel agencies, maybe supermarket chains. The dangerous aspects in what we see these days, are more on the path to reach those objectives: The intention is less on hard work for it, and more on 'someone owes me a Muslim this-and-that', or the intent to destruct the existing, non-Muslim infrastructure.
But the caliphate will never rise from blind destruction, from deliberate senselessly ashed existing walls and organisations. There is no shortcut to success, and as of now, I see the majority of the customers in KFC being Muslims, and contending themselves with a 100% Anglo-American food style, but franchised by Muslims; Halal, and paid for partially by hand-outs due to racial and religious affiliation. Alas, these are not the ingredients from which a global Muslim presence in the tourism and business world are prepared. These are not any basics for dreams of a caliphate. During the times of the caliphate, its success was based on dedication, study, hard work, some freedom of sciences, liberties and exploring the unknown. It is a pity, that so many Muslims these days attribute the successes of the caliphate predominantly to piety and prayers. In reality, the latter only guided the individuals in their strive for the former.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 6
..., Lowly rated comment [Show]
...
written by aris, August 10, 2008 10:52:52
Dear Farish A Noor,
Like you I too wish Muslims nations will unite, pool their resources, share their knowledge, help each other and live the life they want.

1.Shias and Sunnis must learn to respect each other and find common grounds to come together for the purpose of unity.
2.Develop political systems and structure that all Muslims respect as the will of God.
3.Make an exhaustive list of everything Muslims want that will make their lives more meaningful. For example, places of worship, types of homes, buildings and architecture, schools and universities, road and bridges, Cities, towns, villages and holiday resorts, types of communication, types of travel, modes of transport, types of services, types of business and industries, types of currencies, farming and agriculture, marine produce, clothes, perfumes and so on. Next, make a list of what you already have and mark them on the map. Compare list no. 1 with list no. 2. to determine what are needed but missing. The missing items go into list no. 3.
4.Muslim scholars must get together to develop a master Plan. For example – get a map of the world and remove all non Islamic countries so that only Islamic countries are visible on the map. Use list no. 3 to draw up a grand master plan to put up all those missing features on the MUSLIM WORLD MAP.
5.Get moving my friend. You have a lot of work to do. Who knows, you may even win a Nobel price for your effort.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 2
...
written by densemy, August 11, 2008 18:12:10
The global caliphate will falter and die when it comes face to face with caring thinking parents who arent prepared to sacrifice the upbringing of their children to some religious whacko... regardless of how pious he appears
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 0

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
 
Some Images Hosted With
Thank You ImageShack!
 BLOGGERS AGAINST ISA

Powered and Optimized for:
Malaysia Today by MT-TEAM